If the thought of a New York-style pizza brings you immense amounts of joy, then Gioia will be your happy place. This popular New York-style pizzeria leans on seasonal California ingredients in magnif…
A lot of food for 4, though if you order anything other than the formaggio (cheese) pizza, add $5/pie. I loved the marinara sauce the meatballs are in...plenty to dip your crust in!
We ordered two Caesar salads, and the dressing is more of a flavorful oil-based vinaigrette rather than the white creamy version. Delicious!
L
Luis H
5 contributions
4/20/25
• DoorDash order
Overcooked bordeline burnt pizza this time around. Also, $20 chicken wings??!! Wild. I've been a customer for birthdays, celebrations, and weekly pizza until recently. Drop in Quality + high pricing are not a good combo.
D
David P
Local Expert • 181 contributions
10/22/23
• DoorDash order
Loved the crust on these pies, they have that authentic super thin New York style crust.
The Salsiccia Pie was my favorite, the sausage had a good meaty bite to it and the jalapeños gave it a nice amount of spice to it.
The Funghi Pie was also pretty solid if you're a fan od mushrooms.
G
Gregory C
19 contributions
6/30/23
• DoorDash order
I just wanna say congratulations on being my favorite pizza place in sf. I have tried atleast 20 places. these garlic Garlic Knots are so good they come with flavoring and they are soft like a pretzel. I can even save some and reheat and they still have great taste. the pizza is perfect I love thin crust I love the bread everything is so good. my daughter gets so happy when I ask if she wants pizza. cause she knows I'm ordering your pizza. thank u for making my nights easier. 🌙
T
Tori
3 contributions
2/15/24
• DoorDash order
Crust is nice. Hardly any sauce. The mushrooms had a strong flavor that wasn't like a typical cremini -- not necessarily bad, just different. I can see why some really like this pizza, but it wasn't for me. Also, $4 for a bottle of mainstream soda is a little much.
