Home
Broken Arrow
Italian
Jimmy's New York Pizzeria

Jimmy's New York Pizzeria

4.7(200+ ratings)•
Italian
•
Store Info
4.7(200+ ratings)•
$$•Italian
Full Menu
11:00 am - 7:25 pm

Most Liked Items From The Menu

$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time

Most Liked Items From The Menu

Reviews200+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
K
Kelly G
Local Expert • 20 contributions
1/31/25
• DoorDash order
The Calzone was cooked perfectly. It had lots of delicious garlic on top! The Manicotti was also good, with marinara sauce that was well balanced and came with a garlic knot. I will definitely be ordering from Jimmy's again. A nice change from the larger pizza places.
J
Jackie O
Emerging Expert • 41 contributions
12/13/24
• DoorDash order
Finally a REALLY good pizza place on DD!!!! The manicotti was such a treat!! This cheeseaholic was a happy camper! And the salad was fresh & crisp & so much more than the lettuce & croutons usually rcvd! Can't wait to try the pizza. Thank u Jimmy's NY Pizzeria.
C
Caitlin R
1 contributions
2/17/25
• DoorDash order
oh my gosh, so freaking delicious. garlic knots 💯 pizza slices 💯 manicotti 💯💯💯
F
Francis F
1 contributions
1/10/25
• DoorDash order
the food from Jimmy's is always top draw. They have not let me down yet. Delicious food.
C
Carolyn C
2 contributions
10/20/24
• DoorDash order
The Stromboli and the Manicotti are amazing!! Definitely recommend and it doesn't disappoint.
See All

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

By the Slice

Authentic, new York pizza slice made with fresh ingredients sourced daily. All slices come from our standard 24" pizza pie.

Classic Pies

If a slice isn't enough for you, try one of our pizza pies that come in either regular (14") or large (16") sizes.

Five Boroughs Pizza Pies

Not in the mood for a classic pie? We can also do any of the following.

Jimmys Specialties

We can make you a custom pizza or you can try one of our specialties.

New York Appetizers

Start your meal with one of our delicious appetizers.

Hot Pasta

Craving something other than pizza? Try one of our delicious pasta dishes. Made with the finest ingredients and Jimmy's famous marinara sauce. All of our pastas comes with one garlic knot.

Special Diet

Healthy alternatives.

Hot Hero Sandwiches

If you rather have a sandwich, select from served one of our satisfying 8" hot heroes. All sandwiches with classic chips.

Salads

Here at Jimmy's, all of our salads are prepared fresh daily. Choice of Dressings: Ranch, Italian, Vinaigrette or Caesar. **Add grilled chicken to any salad for a fee**

Kids Menu

Desserts

End your perfect meal with a delicious treat.

Drinks

We have many drinks to choose from.

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

Checking if the site connection is secured...