New York Vinny's Pizza
4.5(1k+ ratings)•
DashPass•
Italian•
Store Info
DashPass
4.5(1k+ ratings)•
$$•Italian
Full Menu
11:00 am - 9:00 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
Featured Items
Reviews1k+ ratings • 40+ public reviews
4.5
of 5 stars
J
Johnathon S
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions3/20/23
• DoorDash orderI've had their pies for a while, and they're still legit. My favorite pizza place in my area. The pies are well-crafted and consistently tasty.
I recommend the double pepperoni with green bell peppers and hand-tossed crust with garlic butter.
The cinnamon sticks are great, too, but make sure you order the icing separately if you want that.
E
Edward T
3 contributions1/1/25
• DoorDash reviewOrdered on New Year’s Eve. $90 for a regular pizza and some weird Nutella topped “dessert “ pizza along with two tiny cheesecakes. Pizza crust was chewy maybe not entirely cooked. The stuffed crust was not very good probably because the pizza arrived cold. The dessert was not edible. Maybe they were slammed for the holiday but I have no desire to order again.
D
Daneen C
2 contributions7/24/23
• DoorDash orderThe wings are yuck, wet, undercooked straight microwave quality! Pizza is a ok - NY style but reminds you of mall pizza instead of anything from the Big Apple. Place looks super run down inside. Not for me. Pizza Hut prices and on par with Lil Caesar quality. I would bypass this one.
J
Jennifer H
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions6/14/25
• DoorDash orderThe Tribeca 14"and Cheesy Bread were really good. The Wings order of 8 were not crispy and the hot honey just tasted like honey, with no kick.
Y
Yousaf K
2 contributions3/6/25
• DoorDash orderPlain Cheese 14”Large was super generic and mediocre.
Chipotle Grinder was less than mediocre. Not sure what was chipotle about it. Just had a grocery store bun mayo lettuce and couple chunks of sad chicken.
Nothing about NY in this Vinny.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store