That was one of the best subs I have ever had!! It was the hot sub with roast beef, turkey and ham. I also had a french dip from them as well and it was amazing!! Highly recommend Old City Subs!!
D
Dawn H
10 contributions
5 days ago
• DoorDash order
The sub was absolutely perfect and the Italian pasta salad was above and beyond. Old City sub is really good
T
Thomas J
2 contributions
5/23/25
• DoorDash review
I usually order from here at least once or twice a month. I love their subs usually, as I get just an Italian. This time the buffalo chicken hot sub sounded good so I gave that a whirl. Was very disappointed. The picture shows buffalo chicken tenders, yet what I got was chopped rubbery chicken that seemed like it was from a can. The buffalo sauce was very watery and almost couldn't taste it. The juices from the canned chicken, and sauce made the bread extremely soggy and it was falling apart before I even tried to start eating it and the juices made a mess. They are usually pretty decent, but stay away from that sandwich. I'll go elsewhere now if I want anything other than an itlalian.
A
Allison C
11 contributions
11/18/24
• DoorDash order
Everytime I have ordered this Italian Salad it has been nothing short of amazingly delicious!!
S
Sergio V
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
1/30/23
• DoorDash review
Best Subs in Saint Augustine
Buffalo Chicken Sub with Lettuces and Tomatoes