Old Scratch Pizza is a casual, counter-service, walk-in-only restaurant. Our Neapolitan-style pies are quickly crafted in our 800° wood-burning ovens, and served with 20 taps of local and regional cr…
This store and their staff are top notch. I've eaten from here more than 30 times it's that good. If you're tired of bready pizza and want more flavor, this is your next stop. You won't be disappointed. Get the romesco.
Vegans rejoice!
L
Linda L
1 contributions
2/10/25
• DoorDash order
I've really tried to like Old Scratch, but my second time was as unimpressive as the first. I realize that a Margherita Pizza is not a "loaded" pizza, but I really think it should have more than 5 basil leaves on a 12" pie. Maybe chiffonade the basil and scatter it over the whole pizza? The only part I liked was the crust; it was really flavorful, but not worth the price. Side House Salad was okay, but nothing to write home about.
L
Luke B
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
1/28/24
• DoorDash order
This pizza made me cry. Im an officer in the AirForce and have moved around a good bit. It's been so long since I ate terrific Neopolitan style pizza. Angry Beekeeper Pizza and Margherita Pizza were so amazing they threw me into memories like Proust.
I will definitely come back and order alot. I debate whether I should tell people because I want it to remain my little secret so I can get pizzas fast.
J
JEAN A
16 contributions
7/6/25
• DoorDash order
The pizza always tastes great but...could use a little more time in the oven in general (and now that I remember that, will order well done) but the amount of vegan cheese is way too much and there's no option to order light cheese or make a note
P
Phoebe J
14 contributions
7/9/25
• DoorDash review
My first Dayton pizza from them was terrific (I had additions). The second was overcooked, dry cheese, and toppings dark and dry. I tried again today, even called them; explained, and asked they not overcook again. OK. It arrived burned, had solid cheese with no taste, charred toppings, and crust. Done here.
