I'm reminded of Buffalo Pie! Your go-to neighborhood locations for high-quality Italian classics are Village Trattoria of Maplewood and South Orange. Quick, friendly, and delectable.
The Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich was outstanding. Lots of chicken cutlet that was moist and not dry, the sauce was flavorful and not too salty, and the sesame seed semolina bread was nice and crusty. Overall a ten!
L
Laurie P
2 contributions
12/21/24
• DoorDash review
Just absolutely excellent. Top quality Italian food. Chicken Savoy - best I have had in a very very long time. All very solid dishes. Very large portions, very reasonable prices. Can't go wrong with this place. Extremely satisfied!
S
STEVEN G
Local Expert • 32 contributions
7/19/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered the individual Godfather Pizza and a Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich. Both were excellent. The pizza was very flavorful and had lots of toppings. The sandwich was well made and tasted great. Overall a really positive experience!
V
Victoria B
Local Expert • 29 contributions
6/7/24
• DoorDash order
Large Pizza was super yummy. Sauce and cheese are quality and dough was super crispy.
Side of Meatballs (4) were good, but a little dry for my liking. The sauce they sat in was super super flavorful though and I topped it on my Garlic Bread which was so yummy!!
Garlic Bread was perfection. Will be ordering here again. I typically order from Summit location, but this location is even better.
K
Katelyn H
6 contributions
3/5/25
• DoorDash order
Didnt take a pic because it looked so good to not begin eating!!! The Chicken Francese with the angel hair pasta paired was amazing! Only just wish it came with a bit more pasta for the price point. Not big enough to share. But delicious!!
