Best Italian Restaurants Nearby in Bay Shore
Papa Johns Pizza
4.5
(4k+)$0 delivery fee
Cheesesticks
Original fresh dough covered with Special Garlic sauce, topped with mounds of real cheese made from mozzarella, then baked to a cheesy, gooey goodness. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping!
$8.16
Create Your Own Pizza
Build your own custom pizza and we'll handcraft it for you. With so many delicious options to choose from, your masterpiece is waiting!
$15.76
Pepperoni Pizza
Your choice of crust covered with our signature pizza sauce, real cheese made from mozzarella, and pepperoni. With a pepperoni in almost every bite, it's one of our most popular pizzas.
$15.01
Buffalo Wings
Kick it up a notch with our oven-baked bone-in wings covered in satisfyingly spicy buffalo sauce with just the right amount of heat to enhance our juicy wings. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
$11.04
Pizza Hut
4.3
(2k+)$0 delivery fee
Breadsticks
Nobody does breadsticks like the Hut. Crispy-on-the-outside, soft-on-the-inside, and seasoned with garlic and parmesan, they're perfect with pizza or pasta. Comes with a cup of our delicious marinara!
$8.57
Cheese Sticks
A side everyone can agree on! Get these cheese sticks sprinkled with flavorful Italian seasoning and a cup of our delicious marinara.
$9.69
Personal Pan Pizza
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$8.64
Create Your Own Pizza
Be the Picasso of your next pizza night. Choose from our awesome ingredients and crusts. Onions, sausage, peppers, olives, pineapple-whatever you crave!
$23.06
Subway®
4.5
(900+)$0 delivery fee
Oven-Roasted Turkey
If a classic is what you crave, our thin-sliced Oven-Roasted Turkey is the sandwich for you. It’s full of flavor and made to order with your choice of crisp veggies, melted American cheese, served on our freshly baked, Hearty Multigrain bread.
$10.07
Steak & Cheese
Our Steak & Cheese sandwich is where warm, delicious steak gets topped with melty cheesiness. Get crazy with veggies and sauces to make it what you want.
$11.37
Meatball Marinara
The Meatball Marinara sandwich is drenched in irresistible marinara sauce, parmesan and provolone cheese, topped with whatever you want (no judgement) and perfectly toasted just for you.
$9.34
Tuna
You’ll love every bite of our classic tuna sandwich. 100% wild caught tuna blended with creamy mayo then topped with your choice of crisp, fresh veggies. 100% delicious.
$10.01
Detroit Cookie Company
7.5 mi • 30 min
$0 delivery fee
Newly Added
Birthday Cake Cookie
Funfetti Cake, White Chocolate Chips & Rainbow Sprinkles! Its always yo birthday when you have a birthday cake cookie!
$4.99
Banana Pudding Cookie
A scrumptious banana pudding cookie swirled with vanilla wafers!
$4.99
B-Special Cookie
Our B’Special, The Staff FAVORITE! Like a snickerdoodle cookie but WAY BETTER. Cinnamon & Oreos!
$4.99
Ultimate PB Cookie
The best classic Peanut Butter Cookie you will ever have!
$4.99
Fat & Weird Cookies
4.7
(40+)$0 delivery fee
Cookie Terrestrial Cookie (5 oz)
Cookie.Phone.Home. This Cookie was inspired by that cosmic brownie your mom or dad put in your lunchbox to make you feel extra special every Friday. A chocolatey cookie base stuffed with crunchy galactic meteors, chocolate bits, and chunks of brownies.
Cookies arrive at room temperature and are in sealed packaging to preserve freshness.
From room temperature: We recommend placing them in the oven/air fryer at 350°F for 4-5 minutes or the microwave for 12-15 seconds (individually) is a good alternative. From frozen, we always recommend letting your cookie thaw before reheating for best results.
$5.99
Big Sexy Cookie (5 oz)
Thicc and Salty, just the way our cousin Trace likes it. With just the right amount of salted caramel sprinkled in, this classic buttery chocolate chip cookie has a caramel core hidden inside just waiting to ooze on out.
Cookies arrive at room temperature and are in sealed packaging to preserve freshness.
From room temperature: We recommend placing them in the oven/air fryer at 350°F for 4-5 minutes or the microwave for 12-15 seconds (individually) is a good alternative. From frozen, we always recommend letting your cookie thaw before reheating for best results.
$5.99
Best-Sellers Cookie Pack (5 oz x 4 ct)
Enjoy Fat & Weird Cookie's best-selling flavors with this four-pack. Cookies include Massive Eruption, Cookies Anonymous, Big Sexy, and The Party Animal.
Cookies arrive at room temperature and are in sealed packaging to preserve freshness.
From room temperature: We recommend placing them in the oven/air fryer at 350°F for 4-5 minutes or the microwave for 12-15 seconds (individually) is a good alternative. From frozen, we always recommend letting your cookie thaw before reheating for best results.
$19.98
Pitchin' Tents Cookie (5 oz)
Because that’s what you’ll be doin’ after you take a bite…only because you’ll want to go camping, of course. That’s right, it’s a S’MORES COOKIE! Honey graham dough, tiny & mini marshmallows, made with HERSHEY'S Mini Kisses & HERSHEY'S Chocolate Chips, and a marshmallow chocolate core.
Cookies arrive at room temperature and are in sealed packaging to preserve freshness.
From room temperature: We recommend placing them in the oven/air fryer at 350°F for 4-5 minutes or the microwave for 12-15 seconds (individually) is a good alternative. From frozen, we always recommend letting your cookie thaw before reheating for best results.
$5.99
Americano Pie Bar
4.6
(3k+)$0 delivery fee
Regular Cheese Pizza
8 slices. Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$18.5
Chicken Alla Vodka Hero
Vodka sauce, cherry peppers, and mozzarella. Served with French fries.
$18.35
Fried Mozzarella
Fried Mozzarella Wedges-Vodka Sauce
$11.71
Honey Spice Pizza
8 slices. Spicy sopressata, pecorino, mozzarella, honey drizzle.
$22.53
Our Little Italy
4.6
(6k+)$0 delivery fee
$6 off on $40+
Garlic Knots (Dozen)
Garlic knots mixed with grated cheese, garlic and oil
$5.46
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Breaded chicken cutlet topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese on a hero
$13.26
Mac and Cheese Slice
Macaroni and cheese with mozzarella and chedder cheese on a square pizza crust
$4.93
Pasta Alla Vodka
Penne pasta with a creamy tomato-vodka sauce, garnished with fresh basil. Comes with salad and bread
$17.71
The Cheesecake Factory
4.4
(28k+)$0 delivery fee
French Fries
The Original Topped with Glazed Fresh Strawberries. Our Most Popular Flavor for over 45 Years!
$7.58
Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake
Creamy Cheesecake Layered with Oreo® Cookies, Topped with Oreo® Cookie Mousse and Chocolate Icing
$13.8
Oreo® Dream Extreme Cheesecake
Crispy Crumb Coated Macaroni and Cheese Balls. Served over a Creamy Marinara Sauce
$13.13
Fried Macaroni and Cheese
Served with Fries or Fresh Fruit
$19.85
Buteras
4.7
(500+)$0 delivery fee
$5 off on $35+
Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken breast, marinara, mozzarella, and linguine.
$27.98
Chicken Meatball Pot
Chicken meatballs, marinara, herb ricotta, and fresh mozzarella.
$19.11
Margherita Pizza
Marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
$13.18
Burrata
Red, yellow grape tomatoes, grilled marinated red peppers, balsamic glaze, basil pesto, sundried tomato pesto, and crostini.
$16.25
ITA Kitchen
4.6
(300+)$0 delivery fee
Homemade Ricotta Gnocchi
Truffle cream sauce - vt or sausage meat sauce
$34.67
Eggplant Marco
Fried eggplant, sauteed spinach, sliced tomato, fried fresh mozzarella, caper infused marinara sauce, touch of cream
$20
Patrizia's of Hauppauge
4.6
(1k+)$0 delivery fee
20% off, up to $5
Penne alla Vodka
Served with a side salad.
$17.69
Fioretti alla Boscaiola
Homemade money bags in a mushroom and prosciutto pink cream sauce. served with a side salad.
$19.25
Caesar Salad
dollops of tomato sauce on top, mozzarella on the bottom, basil. Add gluten-free crust for an additional charge.
$15.66
Mario's Pizzeria (Commack)
4.6
(700+)$0 delivery fee
$5 off on $25+
16" - Large Cheese Pizza
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!
$24.1
Garlic Knots
Tossed with Garlic, Oil, Parmesan Cheese & Fresh Parsley. Melted Mozzarella Available
$5.24
12" - Medium Cheese Pizza
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!
$18.78
Plain Slice
Tomato Sauce & Mozzarella Cheese. Click to add Toppings!
$4.67
Mary's Pizza and Pasta
4.8
(700+)$0 delivery fee
Regular Cheese Pizza
Large.
$24.74
Penne Alla Vodka
Pink cream and vodka sauce with touch of prosciutto.
$24.13
Chicken Parm Hero
Chicken cutlets, tomato sauce, and mozzarella on toasted Italian bread.
$16.69
Garlic Bread
(6) Italian breaded mozzarella sticks, served with side of tomato sauce.
$5.79
Buseto Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.5
(200+)$0 delivery fee
Garlic Knots (6)
Tossed in extra virgin olive oil, pesto and fresh Italian herbs.
$4.5
Chicken Parmigiana Hero
Crispy breaded chicken cutlets, topped with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese, served in a submarine sandwich.
$20
Sausage Roll
Sausage, pepper, onions, mozzarella, tomato sauce and Romano cheese.
$12.5
Vinnies Mulberry Street
4.7
(10+)$0 delivery fee
Large Pie 18" (8 Slices)
Breaded chicken cutlet, baked in tomato sauce, topped with mozzarella.
$28.93
Chicken Roll
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
$12.84
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Mixed greens, cucumbers, plum tomatoes, carrots, black olives and red onions.
$31.72
House Salad
Breaded chicken cutlet topped with arugula, diced fresh mozzarella, tomatoes & red onion in balsamic vinegar.
$17.64
Gino's
4.5
(1k+)$0 delivery fee
Regular Pie
18 inch round crust pizza with mozzarella and tomato sauce.
$27.21
Regular Slice
Traditional crust with mozzarella & tomato sauce.
$4.26
Sicilian Slice
Thick crust pan pizza with mozzarella & tomato sauce.
$4.38
Buffalo Slice
Traditional crust with spicy buffalo chicken, mozzarella, &
bleu cheese.
$5.5
Pasta Glory
3.8
(30+)$0 delivery fee
Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine in rich and creamy Alfredo sauce topped with fresh Parmesan cheese.
$19.73
Garlic Bread
Toasted bread coated in hot garlic butter.
$6.35
Penne alla Vodka
Penne pasta coated in a delicious, creamy vodka sauce, and topped with fresh Parmesan cheese.
$19.36
Spaghetti Bolognese
Spaghetti in a traditional Bolognese sauce topped with fresh Parmesan cheese.
$20.07
Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant
4.7
(6k+)$0 delivery fee
Regular Pie
With tomato and mozzarella.
$24.5
Regular Slice
Green salad with caesar dressing and cheese.
$4.34
Garlic Knots
Crispy dough filled with seasoned chicken and melted cheese, and tomato sauce
$5.51
Sicilian Slice
Vodka saauce, fresh mozzarella, pepperoni cups, and Mikes Hot Honey
$4.42
Selita’s
4.4
(40+)$0 delivery fee
Penne Alla Vodka
Vodka pink cream sauce and romano cheese. Served with garlic knots (Limited time offer)
$17.3
Spaghetti And Beef Meatballs
House-made beef meatballs with spaghetti and tomato sauce. served with bread and with your choice of penne or spaghetti.
$17.25
Chicken Francese Dinner
Egg battered chicken scallopini in a lemon butter wine sauce. served with bread and with your choice of penne or spaghetti.
$18.75
Chicken Parm Dinner
Golden fried chicken cutlets with tomato sauce with melted mozzarella. Served with bread and with your choice of penne or spaghetti
$19.95
Angela’s Pizza
4.7
(1k+)$0 delivery fee
Large Pie
Large Cheese Pie
$21.31
Regular Slice
Charred Pepperoni over Vodka Sauce with Hot Honey Drizzle
$3.92
Hot Honey Slice
TELL FLAVOR IN COMMENTS.
--> BUFFALO, SWEET CHILI, CHIPOTLE, GARLIC PARM, BBQ, SICILIAN
$4.8
Chicken Parm (Vodka Sauce) Hero
A grandma style square pie topped with fresh mozzarella and our in house vodka sauce ! Delish!
$13.43
The Pie at Salvatore's
4.8
(1k+)$0 delivery fee
Rave Reviews
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Large)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$28.35
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Small)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$13.8
Original Neapolitan Pizza (Medium)
Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato & Basil.
$26.51
Caesar Salad (Small)
Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated cheese, homemade Caeser Dressing
$11.41
La Famiglia Italian Restaurant
4.7
(400+)$0 delivery fee
Chicken Parmigiana
Serve 2-3 people
$28.1
Alla Vodka with Prosciutto
Linguine, spaghetti, fettucine, cappelini, and penne or rigatoni.
$27.06
La Famiglia Salad
Chopped iceberg lettuce, chopped tomatoes, red onion, cucumbers, roasted peppers, olives, chickpeas and mushrooms in a house vinaigrette
$24.01
Bar Grazie
4.3
(100+)$0 delivery fee
20% off, up to $7
Empanadas Beef
ground beef
$14
Rainbow Cookie Cheesecake
mexican cheese
$12
Eggplant Meatballs
tri colored cheesecake
$14.35
Side Mac & Cheese
mini cannoli
$9
Mama's
4.7
(3k+)$0 delivery fee
Rigatoni Vodka Slice
pink cream, fresh ground beef, parmigiano cheese
$8.56
Sicilian Slice
rich marscarpone, kahlua, espresso, soaked ladyfingers
$5.91
Buffalo Chicken Slice
sicilian cuisine, freshly filled
$8.56
Rigatoni Ala Vodka
panko chicken rollatine style, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, pink cream vodka sauce
$29
Ciao Ciao Trattoria
3.1
(10+)$0 delivery fee
Chicken Alfredo
Your choice of pasta tossed in a creamy alfredo sauce with grilled chicken.
$23.61
Pasta alla Vodka
Your choice of pasta tossed in a creamy vodka sauce.
$20.35
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Classic spaghetti with meatballs and marinara sauce, and topped with fresh Parmesan cheese.
$21.33
Pasta Bolognese
Your choice of pasta tossed in a savory bolognese sauce.
$21.91
Francesco's Trattoria
4.6
(400+)$0 delivery fee
Pasta with Meatballs
Ball of seasoned meat.
$17.3
Grandma Pizza
Stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella, baked with tomato sauce and cheese, served with spaghetti or penne.
$21.24
Eggplant Rollatine
Include breaded veal cutlet, tomato sauce, and mozzarella.
$21.19
Gio's Pizza & Restaurant
4.9
(60+)$0 delivery fee
$6 off on $40+
Pinwheels
Meat: ham, salami, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese or broccoli: broccoli, mozzarella cheese & ricotta.
$2.93
Marcony
4.6
(200+)$0 delivery fee
$5 off on $35+
Large 18" Cheese Pie
Romaine lettuce, croutons and Parmigiano cheese. Tossed in a Caesar dressing.
$22.46
Personal 12" Cheese Pie
Fettuccine in a white cream sauce.
$14.6
Garlic Knots (12)
Lightly fried, and baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella.
$5.95
Small 14" Cheese Pie
Lightly fried and baked with tomato sauce and mozzarella.
$18.22
Filetto's
4.8
(100+)$0 delivery fee
Chicken Parmigiana Entrée
Pan seared breaded chicken or veal cutlets topped with pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
$24.64
Patrizias of Massapequa
4.5
(900+)$0 delivery fee
15% off, up to $10
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded, topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese. *
*
$21.89
Caesar Salad
Breaded, topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese.
$14.81
6. Chicken Parmigiana
Topped with vodka sauce and melted mozzarella
$13.65
Francescos Pizza& Pasta
4.7
(90+)$0 delivery fee
Cheese Pizza (X-Large 18'' (8 Slices))
Classic cheese or create your own pizza, fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
$17.89
Chicken Wings
With sauce. 12 Pieces.
$11.52
Chicken Wings with French Fries
With sauce. 12 Pieces.
$13.16
Vegetable Pizza (X-Large 18'' (8 Slices))
With fresh onions, spinach, garlic,broccoli, mushrooms, and pepper.
$21.79
Bay Shore Italian Delivery FAQs
Is Italian delivery available near me in Bay Shore?
Yes, Italian delivery is available near you in Bay Shore through DoorDash. Enter your address in the DoorDash app or website to find the best Italian options available for delivery near you.
Where can I find the best Italian delivery near me in Bay Shore?
To find the best Italian delivery near you in Bay Shore, look for restaurants with high ratings and user reviews on DoorDash. You can filter by ratings to see the top-rated Italian spots near you.
Where can I find cheap Italian near me in Bay Shore?
For affordable Italian delivery near me in Bay Shore, DoorDash allows you to filter restaurants by price. Look for spots marked with a single dollar for budget-friendly options.
What is open now for Italian delivery near me in Bay Shore?
To see which Italian restaurants are open for delivery in Bay Shore right now, enter your address on the DoorDash website or app. You will be shown a list of Italian places that are currently available for delivery, including their hours of operation.
Can I schedule a Italian delivery in Bay Shore?
Yes, DoorDash allows you to schedule a Italian delivery in Bay Shore at a time that works best for you. During checkout, simply choose the schedule option to set a future delivery time for your order.
How can I get free Italian delivery in Bay Shore?
To enjoy 0 delivery fees on Italian orders in Bay Shore, consider joining DashPass, DoorDash’s subscription service. DashPass members get free delivery on eligible orders from participating restaurants.
How do I pay for my Italian delivery on DoorDash in Bay Shore?
Payment for your Italian delivery in Bay Shore is easy and secure with DoorDash. You can pay through the app using credit/debit cards, DoorDash credits, or other available payment methods. No need to handle cash!
What are the most popular Italian dishes I can order near me in Bay Shore?
Enter your address on DoorDash to discover the most-ordered Italian dishes from restaurants near you.
Top Cuisines in this City
American in Bay Shore near meChicken in Bay Shore near meMexican in Bay Shore near meDessert in Bay Shore near meSandwich in Bay Shore near meFast Food in Bay Shore near meBurger in Bay Shore near meSalad in Bay Shore near meBreakfast in Bay Shore near meCoffee in Bay Shore near meAsian in Bay Shore near meTakeaway in Bay Shore near mePizza in Bay Shore near meSteak in Bay Shore near meLunch in Bay Shore near me
See more