We provide healthy, delicious American deli cuisine at Bagel Toasterie. Bagels, salads, sandwiches, and much more may be found on our menu. Check out our new interactive website – you'll be fascinated…
The bacon egg cheese sandwich I got on a everything bagel with american cheese came out delicious. The one thing I think would make it taste better is if they toasted the bread. Other than that, the sandwich is great. Please give us an option for bread to be toasted or not.
D
Danielle M
Expert local • 62 contributions
12/02/25
• DoorDash order
I'm not very happy with my *EGG PLATER * or . I ask for soft scrambled eggs and I got a big fried egg. The *BURGERS & CHICKENS SPECIALS* looks nothinglike what is pictured. It's the flattest saddest patty you've ever seen. The STARBUCKS FRAPPUCCINO was not white chocolate as ordered, but regular vanilla. I prob won order from this place again.
N
Nicole M
2 contributions
03/09/24
• DoorDash order
Salad is very small. Literally maybe 2 handfuls of lettuce and thats pushing it and about 40 croutons. Bagel was good but I wouldn't spend the money on getting this small salad again
M
Margaret T
6 contributions
16/09/24
• DoorDash order
Dry very thin and cold chicken cutlet I just picked up. I'm suprised because ive ordered from this place multiple times and havent had a problem. If it was delievered I'd understand why it was cold but I picked it up the girl was finishing it up as I got there and I live downthe block so no reason for it to have been cold. I feellike they gave me left over chicken from yesterday im very disappointed
A
Angela S
Expert en devenir • 17 contributions
18/11/23
• DoorDash order
*EGG SANDWICH * was pretty mediocre. Bagel wasn't very good. There are far better bagel stores on LI than this place. Home fries were not that good either. I'd go elsewhere.
