Seriously the best pie i've ever had, and I eat a lot of pie!! Chocolate chess and banana cream are my favorite but every flavor i've had has been perfect. Never heard if Nesselrode before, it was quite sweet but delicious.
S
Sabrina R
2 contributions
05/06/23
• DoorDash order
all the pies we got were delicious. the strawberry dream was my absolute favorite. thought this place was overpriced at first until i tasted the pies -- it was def worth it.
G
Grace T
Expert en devenir • 10 contributions
06/05/23
• DoorDash order
Key Lime Slice is too sour. Banana Cream Slice taste a little overripe, it still taste good though. Classic NY Cheesecake Slice is good! A little too soft and light but good! Chicken Pot Pie's okay. Gotta try something else next time.
D
Dioni D
4 contributions
10/12/22
• DoorDash review
I got the Wild Maine Blueberry slice and the Hudson Valley Apple slice and it was okay. Not a place I would recommend but if I got a sweet tooth and nothing else was open, I'd order again.
A
Avry E
4 contributions
06/10/24
• DoorDash order
The Farm Fresh Pumpkin Slice is a little grainy and on the less sweet side. I would say it's good but not amazing. The Salty Chocolate Chess Slice looked like it was going to be dry but it has a nice moisture content. It's got a robust chocolate flavor with a nice salty finish. Overall a 4/5 experience. I'll definitely try more flavors in the future.