The .Garlic Knots are AMAZING. Very crispy and VERY salty (almost too salty), but they were warm and buttery, so that can be overlooked. The .Large Pepperoni** was soft and chewy. I'm here for Scarefest but if I was local I'd eat here regularly!
J
John B
5 contributions
15/07/25
• DoorDash order
when made correctly, the large NY style pepperoni is one of my 2 favorite pizzas in Lexington. unfortunately, it seems that only 1 person Mondays shift is the only employee that even pretends to make it correctly. he once told me they use a small dough stretch it to the largesize to make the thin crust. so when I complained that my order was wrong and showed the night manager, it threw me off when he said, "It was made with the right dough". The 14 incg pizza i ordered was lees than 10" at the narrowest and 11" at the widest point. I did measure!. the "thin" crust was thick and chewy not thin and slightly crisp.
T
taylor g
6 contributions
17/01/24
• DoorDash order
Bit of a ripoff: Small pizzas are not worth the price at all. Was unfortunately blown away at the small size of the small pizza.... Rolling Oven's small pizza is $17 and bigger than the one I ordered from Stoners. (With more flavorful toppings)
It was good but definitely not worth the price.
I
Ivy G
2 contributions
07/06/25
• DoorDash order
This pizza joint has amazing pizza dough. The bread was cooked perfectly. The issue I had was, I ordered a .Small Calzone , and all I got was bread. I paid extra for .Extra Sauces and extra filling for the .Small Calzone that I did not receive. I was credited 5 dollars when I spent 20 for just bread. Very disappointed.
D
Des C
2 contributions
22/05/23
• DoorDash order
I ordered just a little late and felt pretty bad that I was ordering a pizza the last hour they were open! I was expecting it to be okay - but it was great. The .Small Veggie* is one of the best pizzas I've had in awhile, and one of the best things I've ordered on DoorDash! The .Half Chicken Caesar salad was also so so good, it was a great sized portion and so fresh. Thank you!
