We ordered the 4-pk with the chocolate strawberry cheesecake, caramel chocolate, valentine sugar cookie, and the milk chocolate cookie. All of them look and taste amazing!
T
Tanaya B
3 contributions
3/29/24
• DoorDash order
If only they tasted as good as they looked...
1. Carrot Cake - good but not in any way a cookie. Literally cake and nothing special about it.
2. Milk Chocolate Chip - best texture of all of them. However, the chocolate they use is garbage and it was super vanilla extract flavor forward in taste.
3. Lemon Crinkle - absolutely the worst of all of them and the biggest disappointment. If you truly made yourself believe, you could almost taste lemon. The texture was awful. Dry, dense, and grainy. I've had a crinkle cookie before and they are supposed to be rich and chewy.
4. Double Fudge Brownie - good but just a brownie and a cakey brownie at that. Jimmy John's brownies taste better and are cheaper. Far too sugary and not the greatest chocolate flavor. If they called it a brownie, I'd be less critical but yeah... I wanted a chewy and rich chocolatey cookie.
For $4 a cookie, it just isn't worth it.
L
Lindsay Y
15 contributions
2/12/23
• DoorDash order
The banana peanut butter cookie was my favorite in this batch. The animal cookie was also delicious and nostalgic! I have to say, my top 2 faves so far though, the Peanut Butter and the Powdered Fruit donut cookie.....YUM!!!
A
Amanda H
2 contributions
2/15/23
• DoorDash order
Honestly, best cookies Ive had in my life. They even beat Grandmas (dont tell her)
K
Kelsey C
1 contributions
1/23/24
• DoorDash order
A tiny bit of joy in nice pink box quick delivery and cookies were perfection
