What an improvement! Best breakfast sandwich ever! I order almost everyday from the Bagelry. There was a brief time where there was hardly any bacon in the sandwich. Now, it's perfect! Thanks Bagelry!
A
Alyssa B
4 contributions
7/1/24
• DoorDash order
I've been on a BEC kick recently and the Bacon, Egg & Cheese on a Roll really hit the spot! the bacon was crispy, but not overly crispy, it was the perfect in between, and the over easy egg complimented it perfectly. the roll was so soft too, it was honestly one of the best bacon egg and cheeses I've ever had!
I had the Iced 1/2 Lemonade 1/2 Tea to wash everything down. and it was absolutely delicious! not too sweet but not too tart! it was perfect! can't wait to order from here again!
L
Lauren B
10 contributions
1/25/25
• DoorDash order
It's weird that the everything bagels only have seeds on the bottom. The top is basically a plain bagel. The menu says "black and white cookies" so I thought it was the mini ones but it was just one big cookie. The bagels were not fresh and some felt like they might have been from the day before.
J
Josh D
20 contributions
11/12/24
• DoorDash order
The Bagelry is now our go to place everyday.
Everything is so fresh and tasty. They even read
Your specal instructions and adjust accordingly.
Vinny and crew you guys are great. Best Bagels on LI. Try them yourself, you will see. Thanks AHC Appliance crew.
T
Tom E
6 contributions
10/30/22
• DoorDash order
The Bagelry is a clean bustling store with great bagels , salads, sandwiches and drinks. I've been going there for 20 plus years and have never had a complaint. I won't get bagels anywhere else. If you get delivery, they show up quickly and the order's always right. Go there!
