Mushroom with half bacon, half pepperoni and it was fantastic, as always! I love the amount of toppings - the columbus style totally covered isnt for me, and with this balance the crust is allowed to shine. The sauce is simple and fresh. My go-to pizza in columbus!
C
CM S
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions
10/20/24
• DoorDash review
Ordered a Kevin Bacon and an East Village pie. East Village was solid -- the slabs of fresh mozz are wonderful. Kevin Bacon stole the show though. Everyone LOVED it. Almost fighting over slices. Pepperonis are nice and crisp and the candied bacon is a perfect blend of sweet and savory. Top notch.
S
Susan T
Local Expert • 158 contributions
4/28/24
• DoorDash order
Closest to NY style pizza I've had in Ohio. Crust was delicious but it was too thin in the center of the pizza - my slices flipped down easily and the cheese slid toward the center, leaving the outer third of the pie with little to no cheese. Also, I had to tear the slices apart. This is unacceptable and completely avoidable. Make sure the pie is cut through, guys! Unlike others I've seen reviewed, my pizza wasn't overly charred. All this being said, I loved the pizza and will order it again. I can only eat so much Tommy's.
V
Velia P
2 contributions
3/6/24
• DoorDash order
This pizza is absolutely delicious !! The spice to the pepperoni is nice and mellow, the chew of the crust is amazing and the Ranch Cup is out of this world! Going to order online next time and pick up so that we have better selection!!
N
Nancy H
7 contributions
11/3/23
• DoorDash order
I am a seriously picky pizza eater and this pizza was hands down one of the BEST pizzas l've ever had. I dont even understand hot they make the crust so crispy but still so soft and airy at the same time. The cheese is super good and not greasy too. Bravo Sexton's... BRAVO!!!
