Pizza was good all the toppings were evenly distributed. Good taste.
M
Miguel R
86 contributions
2/9/22
• DoorDash order
Their "Thin Crust" was neither thin, nor crust. It was instead a soft, doughy, normal thickness. It hardly had any toppings, and we all found it extremely salty and threw much of it away. We found the lack of toppings brazen, yet comical.
For the Pan pizza I paid a lot extra for 3 toppings; all of which were crammed in the very center of the pizza. I only ate the Pan pizza because I was hungry and spent a small fortune on this delivery, but it also was not good, just edible.
I thought I'd try the Pepperoni Rolls, but I didn't realize they were submerged in garlic and stunk real bad (my fault for expecting them to be more like Double Dave's).
It was so strong and pungent that it stunk up the entire house. I didn't eat them, so when I threw them away the next morning, I found the garlic grease had bled all the way through the parchment paper and drenched the entire box! It was SO gross and smelled awful.
I was thankful that it did not enter my body. I had taken a single bite last night and tossed the rest this morning. They also didn't include any of the Ranch Dip I selected and I even added a note requesting extra.
I paid more than double what I pay for Little Caesar's and Little Caesar's ingredients are legit, tasty, generous, and cheap! It's been about 10 years since I've had Gatties, and I will never eat their food again. Sad because our family weekend nights used to be all about Mr. G's back in the day.
D
Deborah M
9 contributions
12/14/24
• DoorDash order
Our first time here. Food was great. Dutch Apple Treat® could have been cook longer, dough was slightly raw. OVER ALL.... we'll definitely will be ordering here again!
M
Marcus B
Emerging Expert • 32 contributions
3/25/24
• DoorDash order
NO WAY TO ADD DOUBLE TOPPINGS BECUZ YALL ARE CHEAP WITH THE NORMAL AMOUNT, thats the only thing thats wrong you should straighten out with DD bcuz you are losing money. Quality or service has never been a problem you been a fave for me for over 30 years plus still going!! then i wld gv 5 stars perfecto
Y
Yolanda W
4 contributions
3/11/25
• DoorDash order
Superoni® was decidedly not super. This looks to be a mayberoni at best. Pretty disappointing given the description says there are 50 pieces of pepperoni
