Founded by award-winning pastry chef Christina Tosi, Milk Bar is a sweet shop and dessert empire that first opened its doors in NYC’s East Village in 2008. Milk Bar now has 14 locations churning out w…
Ive been wanting to try Milk Bar for ages and decdes today was the day!I got the Strawberry Shortcake Cake Slice, Marshmallow Brownie Gooey Bar and the Milk Bar Pie Slice.All were delicious but that cake slice is by far one of the best I have ever tasted!The portions are smaller but yo get what you pay for and Milk Bar delivered!Dont forget to try a birthday cake B'Day Latte 12oz because it made me roll over in my grave and im not even dead.Love it and worth the money to me!
C
Chris R
2 contributions
6/22/23
• DoorDash review
I was curious so I ordered from Milk Bar for the first time. I was underwhelmed. The birthday cake slice was so small for $12 and the texture was grainy and had an artifical flavor. The milk bar pie slice was also tiny and tasted like butter whipped with sugar. I have a sweet tooth but both of these items were far too sugary for my liking. Disappointed.
O
Olivia B
3 contributions
3/5/24
• DoorDash order
a tiny slice of cake for literally so much money es after delivery. Frosting tasted sour? Better off paying a little extra for Susie cakes it is WORLDS better and the portion is 3x at least
P
Parichay N
1 contributions
4/28/25
• DoorDash order
Paid $22 for 3 truffles and a cake slice. The cake slice is REALLY tiny for the cost. Just be aware of the size
V
Valerie S
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
2/22/25
• DoorDash order
The cake slice is not comparable to the cost. Extremely small piece of cake for $12! I was expecting close to a Susie's Cake-size slice. It's actually a "minature" slice. Definitely not worth the price. The cake is ok, Susie's Cake is way better and you get two HUGE pieces of cake for $19 instead of a small (less than 5 inches tall), mid-tier slice of cake for $12. I rarely wrote reviews but am upset about this order.
