Our Famous Strombolis has made us famous!
The year was 2008.
The Upper Arlington facility debuted in 2008, more than two decades after the original Westerville location.
In 1997, while engaged to b…
Food quality and temperature is always consistent. Never have had a bad meal. Great value and I love that they are on delivery services now. I moved from UA and always missed this place. Glad I can get it delivered. Can't go wrong with the Stromboli's or pasta dishes. The Nutella Stromboli is the bomb!!
K
Kaleigh L
14 contributions
5/17/25
• DoorDash order
DELISH!!! The Build Your Own Build Your Own Build Your Own Stromboli (SMALL) (SMALL) and Cannolis are 10/10, the House Salad (SIDE) (SIDE) was good also! The house Italian dressing with it was a little sweet for my taste, but still not bad. Will def be ordering from here again!
B
Bekah G
5 contributions
6/23/24
• DoorDash review
this is not how carsonnis used to be. it used to be the best. Ever since ownership change, the sauce is different every time. it lost the homemade taste. The Stromboli is smaller with thicker crust and less ingredients inside. it's a shame because carsonnis was by far the best homemade Italian restaurant in the Columbus area. Their baked ziti is also different. the change in sauce is their biggest mistake. Everytime we can't wait for it and since then every time we're sadly disappointed in the changes.
T
Teresa S
1 contributions
2/15/25
• DoorDash order
had the build your own stromboli, boneless wing and tiramisu. Stromboli is very good as are the wings, I am very picky about blue cheese dressing, theirs is fantastic as well as their ranch. This is my first time trying Carsonies, food was fantastic. Definitely will order again.
E
Erica L
22 contributions
3/31/25
• DoorDash order
Build Your Own Stromboli (SMALL)Frank's Pizza (8") tasted good but the pizza dough was raw under the toppings and the cheese wasn't melted all the way. Chicken Carsonie tastes great... The Alfredo sauce tastes good but it's a thinner sauce rather than a thicker Alfredo (just an FYI). Ranch (8oz) Alfredo (8oz) were homemade and delicious.
