Ordered #76 Mike and Rich Follow the Bubble for my daughter and #3 Ari's Open Door for myself. It's absolutely fantastic. Flavorful and already wanting more. Love me some Matzo Ball soup, it was great and came with a huge portion of bread for dipping. Also ordered the Apricot Noodle Kugel and it was some of the best I've ever had! I'm from Atlanta visiting and wish they had a location near me.
G
Gretchen S
2 contributions
4/2/25
• DoorDash order
I don't mind the prices since the portions are usually enormous, but my sandwich barely had any tuna (I'm still hungry after a Katzinger's sandwich!), plus the bread tasted a little stale, and they gave me the wrong kind of pickle. Very disappointing all around.
M
Molly C
1 contributions
2/6/25
• DoorDash order
One of my favorite spots in Columbus! You cant go wrong with the classic #1 Katzinger's Reuben (theres a reason it's listed as #1 on the menu!!) or Big Bob's Belly Bouncer. If you're a vegetarian, Seth's Bella MushReuben is a great choice. The Potato Latkes are a must--- use both applesauce AND sour cream for dipping to get the full experience. The pickles are made in-house, all the desserts are wonderful....this place is a total gem and a staple whenever I have visitors and want to give them the full Columbus experience.
D
Deana W
5 contributions
5/16/25
• DoorDash order
They have always had the best carrot Carrot Cake (Slice) in Columbus! The chicken sandwich was absolutely amazing as always! the price is a bit high but so so worth it !
R
Renee B
Local Expert • 51 contributions
4/20/25
• DoorDash order
Carrot Cake (Slice) was a decent size; couldn't quite tell if it was homemade; would have been better warm. NYCC (Slice) Plain cheesecake was good. Loved the crust.
