I'm new in town and this place was open on Thanksgiving. The Omnivore was very good. The toppings were chunky, flavorful, and fresh. I really enjoyed the pizza sauce that came on it and the beef sausage gave the pizza a very unique and delicious flavor. The 6 Wings with garlic parmesan sauce were slightly overcooked but still good. As for the Fried Mushrooms, they were nothing special or unique but if you like them at other places you will like these. The NY Giant Cheesecake was a huge piece and was very rich and creamy. Plenty of leftovers for tomorrow too. I will definitely order all of this again.
J
Jamie J
1 contributions
5/18/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered the Valentinos's Special and that was probably the driest pizza I've ever had. The dough was awful, tasted like a stale cracker. I hate to give a bad review but Chuck E. Cheese makes a better pizza. This was beyond bad.
M
Megan C
4 contributions
5/3/25
• DoorDash order
The Alfredo was pretty good however I thought the pictures the on the menu were misleading. Very small portion of noodles and an extremely small Tiramisu cake for $9. Not worth the price.
L
Lacy B
13 contributions
12/17/22
• DoorDash order
This is literally my go-to place! it's always so delicious! the mozzarella sticks are hands down the best I've ever had from anywhere! the pizza is absolutely perfect every time! It has the perfect amount of sauce to crust to cheese ratio. I can't rave about Valentinos enough
C
Cece C
8 contributions
4/4/25
• DoorDash order
Omg!! The pizza has to be one of the best Ive ever tried! So delicous! The wings had such a good flavor and were really crispy, wonderfully made.
