Every flavor I got was amazing! I had Ube Brownie Pint, Dark Matter Brownie Batter, and Salty Oreo Pint. I don't know which one I like the best. They're all so darn good! They Ube Brownie Pint tastes exactly like Brownie Batter which I love! Ben and Jerry's used to make a Brownie Batter ice cream which was my absolute favorite ice cream in the whole world but they stopped making it. They have one now that supposedly has a Brownie Batter core, unfortunately, it doesn't taste like Brownie Batter. It tastes like chocolate frosting which I hate. Now I have Afters to give me the Brownie Batter fix that I love. The Salty Oreo Pint is fantastic as well. I wish they had more flavors on the Doordash app. I think if you go to the store they have a bunch more. I just wish they'd share them Doordash.
C
Christopher S
2 contributions
6/3/23
• DoorDash order
Definitely not $10/pint ice cream. Packaging and flavors make it seem super premium until you read the ingredients. Tasty but texture & value is mid at best.
K
Kara D
5 contributions
4/27/25
• DoorDash order
The flavors are good, but the heavy, gooey consistency was not for us. Plus, there’s so much food coloring in the ice creams that you know when your body finishes processing it (to put it politely). 😳
J
Jill D
73 contributions
12/9/22
• DoorDash order
Milk & Cereal is my most favorite ice cream in the entire world! Buttery corn flake ice cream, it's like eating the end of your cereal but frozen! All of their flavors are amazing, top quality! A1
S
Sophia B
1 contributions
9/13/22
• DoorDash order
Brownie batter was good but it wasn't like quite worth the hype. Doesn't really taste chocolatey or like brownie.. Ben and Jerry's version is much better if you're craving this type of flavor. Again not bad, but not really giving what it's descripted to taste like.