The milk and cereal was cool Frosted Flakes and vanilla ice cream something I've mixed on a munchies night before but I didn't love this one... now the Cookie Monster was the Bomb!!! I'd definitely buy it again!
D
Dylan H
5 contributions
9/29/22
• DoorDash order
Ice cream is fantastic, but they could use some kind of sealant on the pints to protect against spills or tampering.
Def recommend the Cookie Afters Ice Cream Pint-Cookie Monster and Afters Ice Cream Pint-Cookie Butter as a staple, and the Afters Ice Cream Pint-Strawberry Cookie Crunch is a great alternative to the usual flavors while still giving you the classic cookie flavor you want!
T
Takoda S
6 contributions
5/25/22
• DoorDash order
I finished that entire pint of Cookie Monster in one sitting, it was so good.
D
David B
9 contributions
1/28/25
• DoorDash order
The Dark Matter Brownie Batter is by far the best flavor, but expect to get black lips afterwards. The Chocolate Chip Cookie and Cookie Butter are really just a must avoid they both taste highly artificial accompanied with far too many calories for the flavor. While thr Strawberry Cookie Crunch and Milk & Cereal are decent, unless youre really craving those specific flavors I could not recommendthem. Lastly the Jasmine Milk Tea is pretty strong so make sure you really enjoy Jasmine Tea if you're buying this!
Y
Yawn S
10 contributions
1/8/24
• DoorDash review
The ice cream tastes fine until you read the ingredients. The quality of ingredients in this ice cream is no better than what you would get at a dollar store.
