the Cookie Butter Ice Cream (1 pt) is freaking awesome.
Highly recommend. has become just an all around favorite of mine that I try to pick some up anytime I'm sorta nearby
J
Justin S
7/14/25
• DoorDash review
TLDR: Ice cream is good, but consistently arrives melted. Ube Brownie was delicious, as was Cookie Butter, but both were almost liquid. These orders are fulfilled by DashMart. They used to use foil bubble wrap insulation (which worked great) but quit doing that a year ago. I no longer order ice cream from DashMart, but I didn't know that Afters was fulfilled from DashMart. It's unfortunate, because the ice cream is otherwise delicious.
K
Kieu Michelle NA N
4/27/24
• DoorDash order
Probably my new favorite ice creams, love ube w/ brownies; really rare to find these kinds of flavors. The cookie butter, if you like Biscoff cookies or cinnamon then you'll love this flavor.
C
Cierra W
3/22/24
• DoorDash order
The Afters Cookie Monster Ice Cream (1 pt) was amazing, really thought it was going to be my favorite but the Afters Dark Matter Brownie Batter Ice Cream (1 pt) was beyond expectations, amazing icecream
J
Julian L
7/22/24
• DoorDash order
The Cookie Monster Ice Cream (1 pt) was my favorite one I tried. very yummy
