Ally Cat Pizza and Subs
4.3(100+ ratings)•
DashPass•
Ally Cat Pizza and Subs•
Store Info
DashPass
4.3(100+ ratings)•
$$•Ally Cat Pizza and Subs
Alley Cat Subs & Pizza located in the heart of Newark is a neighborhood favorite 🍕
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Reviews100+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.3
of 5 stars
A
Amanda B
3 contributions11/5/23
• DoorDash reviewBest Italian I've ever had!! Perfect amount of fillings and dressing and bread was nicely toasted! Their ingredients are prepped fresh every day and all sauces and dressings are homemade! My sub held up quite well for leftovers, didn't get soggy or anything. Support your local pizza joint!!
T
Twanna W
7 contributions1/25/24
• DoorDash orderOrdered for the first time and was really disappointed. The Pep and cheese looks nothing like the picture, only had about 15 cup pepperoni on the XL pizza. The taste wasn't any better. It was like cardboard and tasted like bowling alley or skating rink pizza. The Italian sub looked like it was on a hotdog bun and for $8 I was expecting more. Disappointing all the way around.
M
Michelle R
Local Expert • 32 contributions11/2/24
• DoorDash orderLasagna was just okay. Chocolate cake was good but looked nothing like the photo advertising it. Cheesecake tasted okay but quality was poor. Nothing at all like a New York cheesecake. Overall disappointing order.
J
Jennifer C
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions11/19/23
• DoorDash orderPizza was delicious but sub was very small for the price
U
Uriah M
1 contributions9/22/24
• DoorDash orderThe Italian Cat was excellent! The only thing missing was some melted cheese.
Pizza Sub was not so great, definitely didn't look like the pic. Had a little bit of pepperoni and a small bit of cheese and a small bit of sauce. Not very flavorful.
Dumpster Tots were quite good, could definitely use more jalapenos next time but that's a personal preference.
Alley Cat Fries they were just regular plain fries, didn't match the description at all. Was disappointed :/
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
À La Carte Menu
Subs
Double the meat on any sub for an additional charge.
Pizza
Dinners
All alley cat dinners are made fresh daily with homemade meat sauce. Add meatballs to your dinner for an additional charge.