From a native Mainer, hands down Amatoes is my favorite place to eat! Italian-American food is my favorite. I was raised on Amatoes and always such a special treat in my family since I can remember. I have frequently ordered from them three times a week. I have recently started using door dash and couldn't be more pleased. I just ordered a spaghetti and meatball dinner, veggie pazzo stuffers and a large ham Italian. I'm eating my fill and will have leftovers for the entire week! It was so hot when it arrived I had to wait to eat it. Yes I ordered all of this just for myself and no delivery fee and more reasonably priced than any place to eat in town. The pazzo stuffers in the picture actually had 2 more, but I ate them before I took the picture.
B
B H
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
5/3/25
• DoorDash order
I feel like they
Just get me at my core.
They neverlet me down or mess up
Its just perpetual perfection
L
LK S
Emerging Expert • 22 contributions
3/30/25
• DoorDash order
everything was fine but the Garlic Bread Stick was burnt, and you could smell how burnt it was before even opening the package
F
Ford S
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
9/30/24
• DoorDash order
Okay food at decent pricing. Quality is mixed, steer away from anything that uses onion, olives, or green peppers to mitigate quality issues. I should note for the restaurant that if you cover raw onions/peppers in cheese before cooking, you'll still end up with raw onions/peppers. Also, you're not supposed to use the onion shell or pepper stem in cooking. The olives, both black and greek, just kinda suck... and I love olives. Meats and sauces aren't great, but certainly not bad.
I've ordered here a few times, it's good for cheap pizza/pasta cravings for groups, but I don't come here when I want "great" Italian food or pizza. If you want something consistently tasty/good/filling, get the stuffers.
S
Sasha L
5 contributions
5/22/23
• DoorDash order
My BLTs are usually good from Amatos but today's arrived with no mayo, burnt bread, and very little bacon. Whoever assembled the sandwich today was either really busy or undertrained.
