The first American Pie Pizza location was at 9709 Maumelle Blvd. in January of 2004.
In 2010, we built a third shop in West Little Rock, across the street from Lander's Toyota, on Colonel Glenn Road a…
I ordered from here two days in a Row! It was so good! I had tried their spaghetti without meatballs and it was so delicious I decided to have it for lunch the very next day! It's really hard to find a good spaghetti and I'm so glad I found one! Plus the garlic bread is delicious! It's the perfect size and the right amount ! They always included silverware and napkins!
Don't hesitate to order from here !
E
Elizabeth S
Emerging Expert • 55 contributions
5/1/22
• DoorDash order
First time trying this place and I was pleasantly surprised. My spaghetti with no meatballs was very good . The noodles the sauce and the garlic bread were delicious! My husband loved his Supreme pizza but was a bit small for him . I will need to get him the 10" or 14" next time. The 8" is better as a small pizza for someone . Ingredients are good quality. I loved how well is was packaged and presented. They didn't leave anything out and the food was Hot! Definitely hit the spot ! Thanks so much !
Z
Zoee W
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
12/31/23
• DoorDash order
The White Cheese Dip was decent. In my opinion, it's a little overpriced for the amount of cheese dip, but not crazy. The Mozzrella Cheese Pizza (10") was okay. I've definitely had better. It would be nice if sauce/dip options were available.
E
Elizabeth S
Emerging Expert • 55 contributions
5/5/22
• DoorDash order
Okay so I have ordered from here a total of 3 times. I was happy with the first time and super happy with the second time . However this last time I ordered my noodles were really mushy and not good. It was pretty disappointing because I know how good it can be and this time it just wasn't it. Also I requested no bacon bits on the salad because I'm vegetarian and they did put the bacon bits on so I couldn't eat it.
They also forgot forks which I requested and staying in a hotel i definitely need them. Other than that the sauce is always good the portions are generous and the garlic bread is very good. They packaged everything nicely and the food was hot.
Im really hoping it was just a one time thing because I would love to give this place another try again!
A
Amy Y
8 contributions
6/12/25
• DoorDash order
I love American Pie Pizza. Unfortunately, this wasn't the best pie from there. It was barely cooked fully. The crust still had the uncooked wheat taste. I consider this a one-off occurrence, however. I'll still be ordering my pepperoni w/ extra Mozzarella Cheese Pizza (14")!
