This was our first time ordering and it didn't disappoint! We got the Peperoni Pepperoni Special (House Favorite!) Pie and the White Pie (we added caramelized onions and sausage). The crust was thin and chewy, which I loved, and the toppings were flavorful! Would recommend!
S
Samantha F
14 contributions
7/25/23
• DoorDash order
Cheese Pie always hits, but the Chicken Tenders are overpriced for 3 half breaded pieces. I wanted a basic cheeseburger and selected "no" to each topping listed on the app only to find out it comes with pickles (which I do not like). They also forgot the extra cheese I paid for. Other branches of Andys are much better.
C
Christopher M
3 contributions
9/16/24
• DoorDash order
We received a hamburger instead of the Charred Broccolini (disappointing for the vegetarian eating dinner with us) and the Old Bay Fries were soggy and not cooked through. The Ceasar salad is WAY too small for almost $10. The pizza was wonderful, but the sides were definitely disappointing.
C
Chetan S
1 contributions
5/9/24
• DoorDash order
I've been a patron of Andy's for many years now. I'm sure they haven't been immune to post-pandemic issues but their quality has gone down significantly the last few months. Burnt crusts and ingredient reduction are becoming the norm rather than one-off flukes — my wife jokes that it's burnt and soggy at the same time. I don't say all this lightly as Andy's was our absolute favorite pizza joint in DC. Hopefully they figure out how to get back to what they used to be.
A
Ayawna W
4 contributions
3/8/25
• DoorDash order
Wings were Super Duper Fresh but barely sauced and delicat spicy but tasty. I order 2 Slice Combo!and the crust is great. Possi a whole pie next time. Sauce is fresh quality tomato. Tad bit more cheese. A whole pie may offer the gooey cheese I saw as a review.
