Wow hands down The Best Pizza. Seriously and we've ordered pizza 1-2x month for the past 20+ years in Fairfax. And the pizzas are large enough to more than justify the price.
T
Theresa V
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
8/6/24
• DoorDash review
Ordered a large cheese pizza for delivery 8/6/24. Extremely disappointed esp after having Andy's at Atlas Brew Works several times when living in Navy Yard and noting it as the best pizza. The pie came cold, had barely any sauce and essentially no cheese. I felt like I was just eating crust. I will try to give this location another chance and update my review accordingly.
R
Ryma L
2 contributions
5/18/25
• DoorDash order
I've ordered and eaten at Andys many times. I've come to enjoy a NY style in NoVA. But the two Cheese Pies I ordered were terrible. Barely any cheese - and mostly tomato sauce with a "blistered" (read burnt) crust. When I called the store to complain, I was told someone who be in touch to "rectify" the order instead of offering either (a) a prompt refund or (b) remaking my order. These are the type of customer service experiences that stick and will make me think twice before ordering from Andy's again.
E
Ecca C
3 contributions
1/26/25
• DoorDash order
Knew the area and was skeptical of the price point. Went straight to the reviews and they did not steer me wrong. Well worth the price, slice sizes ideal. I am excited to try the other pizza combinations.
S
Susan B
4 contributions
6/19/24
• DoorDash order
The pizza was delicious with lots of pepperoni!! It is also huge and worth every penny!!
