HUGE slices! The Artichoke Slice was exactly as described - but very thick. The Basille's Slice was super thin and crispy. The Vodka Square had wonderful flavor - perfect Sicilian texture. The Artichoke Slice was actually thicker than the Square! I just wish everything arrived a little warmer because it was nearly cold by time it was delivered but thats to be expected with any pizza delivery. Extra sauce on the side for $.50 was super small cup so if you need alot of sauce keep that in mind.
B
Barbara S
Emerging Expert • 29 contributions
5/13/25
• DoorDash order
Artichokes are a favorite, so I really expected to like this a lot. But, the dough was thick & under-cooked, so I mostly tasted raw dough instead of artichokes. It was also very chewy. I hope reheating left-overs on the stove will make it taste better after cooking the dough more? The pie was absolutely gigantic.
V
Valerie L
2 contributions
10/9/23
• DoorDash order
I know some people may think it's overpriced, and I do understand . But the pizza is just so good that to me, it's worth the splurge. I have had it so often since they opened in New Brunswick and they are 100% my go to pizza spot. Can't be topped for me!
S
Shanayia W
7 contributions
12/11/23
• DoorDash order
First timer and im in loveee!! The sauce on the Staten Island Slice and the toppings combo is very flavorful. I love the thin crust. Mestballs tasted fresh, juicy and flavoral as well. Im looking to try other pizza toppings in the near future.
R
Rachael W
4 contributions
9/25/23
• DoorDash order
DELICIOUS!!!! I order a vodka sicilian slice and meatball slice both very flavorful and soooo good!!!
