Our local Long Island community has been served with pride by Bagels Your Way Cafe. Bagels Your Way Cafe is the New York bagel cafe benchmark as one of the original "Bagel Cafes" on Long Island. Every…
My new for breakfast they follow instructions and aren't crazy expensive
J
James C
14 contributions
5/18/25
• DoorDash order
Cream cheese not freshly made. Overowering scallions and vegetables must have come from a tub. Bagels looked promising on the outside but same fluffy white bread as everyplace else. Egg sandwiches were perfect and delicious.
T
TERESA O
95 contributions
1/18/25
• DoorDash order
Egg Sandwich just as I like my breakfast . Very good!
D
Dave W
Local Expert • 72 contributions
7/7/23
• DoorDash order
Egg salad excellent, ham very good as was bagel , drinks; home fries are overly spiced for my liking , wish there was a ' natural' home fries option or french fries option
D
Dave W
Local Expert • 72 contributions
7/3/23
• DoorDash order
Egg salad very good as usual; tuna salad tasty , generous portion; potato cubes as well
