The Restaurant opened in 1972 in what used to be the Barbagallo Family farm field. We have grown to be one of the largest privately owned restaurants in Syracuse. In 2017 we opened The Sleep Inn & S…
love this place I always order. Great tasting food.
B
Brian F
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
5/17/24
• DoorDash review
I ordered the $13 open meatball sub. It was not a sub. It was half a piece of bread with three meatballs. I also got the mac and cheese dinner and it was truly disgusting. It didn't taste cheesy at all. It tasted like mayonnaise, like warm pasta salad. I threw it out. The Caesar salad had a lot of chicken which was good but not that much romaine lettuce. The extra dressing I paid for was a waste. I like these guys so I'm sad it was so disappointing.
L
Lynette W
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
2/14/25
• DoorDash order
The fish was crispy and cooked perfectly. It was a little small, but thats ok. The coleslaw was good. The Mac n cheese...I was not a fan. It was sweet and tasted like bananas. I would order again with a different side. Just my opinion of course.
D
Dave O
5 contributions
6/3/25
• DoorDash order
Chicken riggies are fireeeeeeeeee
E
Erich S
Emerging Expert • 65 contributions
4/30/23
• DoorDash order
So, the food was good...but, the Barbagallo's Favorite says in it's description that it's "over pasta" so when it gave me side options, I didn't want to pick pasta as my side, I got onion rings. Couple meatballs and sausages sitting in a foam container rolling around. No pasta. Definitely should be made more clear that you have to actually choose pasta as your side dish.
