This restaurant was recommended by the hotel concierge. We ordered a small pizza and it did not disappoint. We ordered the Create Your Own Pizza (Small) - great crust and toppings. If your are in town - you have to eat here!
B
Bridget G
Emerging Expert • 29 contributions
5/5/23
• DoorDash order
Usually good but there was barely any sausage, barely any toppings at all. It was like getting a cheese pizza. I ordered double sausage, mushroom and green pepper. I paid for double sausage and there wasn't even the amount without the double. And it was doughy. I had to bake it before eating. Very disappointed.
S
Sister Sharon D
1 contributions
2/16/25
• DoorDash order
The pizza,- perfect! the chilli, completely dumped into the pastic baggie, and no jalapeño on the side as ordered, -DoorDash delivery was sure to let me know kindly, that it was packed so tightly and was this way when he picked it up-- see photo. Mushrooms soggy , ugh! I visit from Chicago and brag about Barnaby's pizza, I think they need to find another way to package their chilli, whichmy mom & uncle said was deliciously prepared :/
S
Sharon H
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
12/4/22
• DoorDash order
I ordered a pizza with pepperoni on all of it, plus sausage and mushrooms on side b, and Canadian bacon on side a. Side a came with just pepperoni. Everything else was on side b. I also ordered a "Tossed Salad (Full)" with tomatoes, cheese, bacon bits and eggs. It cost me more than $7 and I wish I could upload a pic of it because I can't believe I paid that much for this. Hardly any cheese. No bacon at all. Oh, and I ordered French dressing and got ranch instead. Everything tasted good. I still love their pizzas, but this was not a great experience. I'll never order another salad from them.
E
Erick S
1 contributions
4/15/23
• DoorDash order
Ive been a fan of Barnaby's for over 40 years. Pizzas are great. This was disappointing though. I ordered a large with sausage and mushroom. Once delivered, I found I was sent a large with sausage and mushroom on half and cheese on half. For $40 I expected more.
