Ordered the Little Italy Sub and Pullman Calzone, along with Statue Of Liberty Cheesesticks and a Brownie.
Not disappointed at all! The sub especially was among the best sandwiches I've ever eaten from a pizza restaurant. The calzone and cheese sticks were equally delicious, and I recommend an extra Marinara Cup for dipping!
The brownie was very rich and chocolatey. Crispy on the edges, gooey in the middle.
If you want to try a good pizza or a sandwich from someplace besides the usual chains, you can't go wrong here.
B
Brittany Z
2 contributions
10/7/23
• DoorDash order
Normally I love BCP but tonight was a big city disappointment. We paid 23$ for a large pizza (just for the specialty pizza) that was room temp at best when it got here, as well as the macaroni bites, if they were straight out of the fryer they might have been good but they were mush really. Maybe poke some holes in the top of the packaging so condensation doesn't build up as much? Not meaning to be rude with that, just genuine assistance offered. This isn't the stores fault I know, which is why I'm giving a 4* but it's still kind of frustrating.
A
Amanda S
Local Expert • 68 contributions
5/13/25
• DoorDash order
This will be my first and last time I order from here. I ordered a diet Mountain Dew because I'm a diabetic and they sent regular Mountain Dew, I did not get sauce on OR with my wings, the ham sandwich had hardly any meat and what it did have was so hard I couldn't chew it and the bread was super soggy, the cannoli filling was straight gritty pure sugar icing. I got it for my kids and even they couldn't stand it.. the quality of food and prep is very poor. $50 down the toilet!
A
Amanda S
Local Expert • 68 contributions
6/21/25
• DoorDash order
The pretzel bread was really hard to chew because it was super tough but even worse it was so salty I couldn't stand to even eat it. It was completely covered in a crazy amount of salt. The macaroni bites were mushy and tasted burnt like burnt oil or grease or something dirty, it was just gross. The beer cheese tasted kind of off, and the sticker said it was made Monday and it's now Saturday. But compared to everything else it wasn't as bad.
S
Syndy S
Emerging Expert • 29 contributions
7/30/23
• DoorDash order
The Pretzel Knots where so salty I couldn't eat them. The knots Where also the size of a quarter! So small and disappointing! The Mac-N-Cheese Wedges where soggy.
