bobby bay's sandwich shop
4.8(500+ ratings)•
DashPass•
American Traditional•
Store Info
DashPass
4.8(500+ ratings)•
$$•American Traditional
Elevated, Chef-Driven Sandwiches & Salads. Our mission is to redefine and elevate the sandwich experience through premium ingredients, creative flavor exploration, and warm hospitality.
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
Reviews500+ ratings • 50+ public reviews
4.8
of 5 stars
J
Jade H
Emerging Expert • 11 contributions3/21/25
• DoorDash reviewIm telling you right now, THEIR FOOD IS AMAZING!!!!! I visited their location first before I decided to order on DoorDash, and I got the Pilgrim and a side salad with ranch dressing. Super delicious! The Pilgrim was loaded! The cranberry mayo is delightful. The salad was huge! The ranch dressing was so darn good! I ordered on DoorDash a few days later and got the Don Parma and the Cobb Salad. Omg!! Delicious is an understatement! The fig jam complimented the proscuitto and mozarella so well! Do not hesitate
to try this establishment out! You will not regret it!
B
Brittany R
4 contributions3/13/24
• DoorDash orderFirst time ordering from here. The Bobby’s Cheesesteak was delicious. We loved the fresh made bread. The Puebla Salad was fresh and filling. The chicken was cooked perfectly and there was lots of it! The jalepeno ranch dressing and pickled onions made the salad!!
C
Chris H
1 contributions1/21/25
• DoorDash orderPlace is dynamite. Great burgers and sandwiches. Salads too. Order is always correct, nicely packaged.
J
J S
1 contributions4/18/24
• DoorDash orderWhat a great find of a sandwich shop!! These are some of the best sandwiches in Lancaster for sure -- fresh ingredients and inventive menu. The Sicilian was incredibly tasty and fresh, the Don Parma had a great balance of savory and sweet and the hot chicken Nashville Hot Sandwich was thick and juicy with the perfect kick. Get the truffle Tuscan Fries as well....so delicious!!
T
Tammy R
Emerging Expert • 14 contributions2/14/24
• DoorDash orderFries were delicious and perfectly salted! Cheesesteak excellent, on par with a Philly *from* Philly. We weren't sure about the truffle whiz, so got in on the side, but it was fantastic and ended up on the sandwich. Pilgrim very tasty, but needed more cranberry flavor. The bread at this place is BOMB! Would order from here again.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store