hard to top this place for sandwichs. got the special pastrami/cornbeef swiss sub. i thought it was a sandwich but huge amount of meat and melt in your mouth. had them add saurkraut even though i didn't know was gonna be cold. delicious. also, got a knish for the first time. will definitely order again. love this place
C
Cheryl O
3 contributions
4/7/25
• DoorDash order
Italian - Whole SubDirty Chips Maui Onion (2 oz Bags)Antipasto
Seems to be the best Doordash value. Brooklyn Pickle never disappoints. Sub was fat with meat and cheese. Salad was huge and fresh!
C
Cheryl O
3 contributions
6/18/25
• DoorDash order
AGAIN...YOU CANNOT GO WRONG
Brooklyn is the best deal; quality, serving size is high. Tuna sub and macaroni salad. Will feed me 2 meals. For the pice...can't be beat.
E
Eric N
1 contributions
1 day ago
• DoorDash order
Ordered grilled Reuben, received cold corned beef sandwich with only Russian? Potato salad has huge chunks of strong white onion, prolly 50/50 to the potato. Literal half of a hard boiled egg in the middle of the salad. Dressing bland and flavorless. Disappointing this is what the Pickle has become.
S
Suzanne B
1 contributions
10/2/24
• DoorDash order
The Brooklyn Pickle Special never disappoints! Two meals easily from the whole sandwich. And I always have to get the rice pudding too!
