Everything was delicious. The turkey breast sandwich was loaded with meat. The only "down" side is that the bread breaks too quickly and the sandwich is hard to eat without being messy. The rice pudding is the best, with creamy rice and lots of whipped cream on the top.
S
shayla r
4 contributions
5/6/25
• DoorDash review
this was my first time trying brooklyn pickle and it was overall really tasty! i ordered the whole reuben sandwich and the proportion was extremely generous. the sandwich was loaded and i got full just from one half so i'll be saving the rest for dinner lol. i also got the macaroni salad and it was delicious :) lastly, i got the cheesecake with cherries for dessert but it was not my favorite. it had a funky aftertaste, almost like it was spoiled? i'm not sure if that's usually how it's supposed to taste but i probably won't order that again. not gonna take a star off cause everything else was perfect.
T
Thomas T
2 contributions
2/3/25
• DoorDash order
I had the Brooklyn special and it was very fresh and a lot bigger than expected. They went above and beyond with my sandwich. It tasted amazing.
J
John paul B
5 contributions
9/11/24
• DoorDash order
Along time ago there was only one place to get a great corned beef sandwich. Sadly that place no longer exists. But our prayers have been answered. Brooklyn Pickle has delivered the best corned beef sandwich in town. Want your moneys worth and more. BP is the place
M
Marilyn L
Emerging Expert • 33 contributions
8/16/24
• DoorDash order
The turkey was superb. It is white meat but cut into small pieces so it's not dry. You could put a couple more tomato slices on the sandwich. All in all, very good.My guest enjoyed her special. She asked for the protein to be heated, and it was. That sandwich was also awesome.
