Brooklyn Pickle is a well-loved sandwich shop from Syracuse, NY featuring giant sandwiches and subs, daily homemade hot specials and fresh baked desserts.
Started in 1975, Brooklyn Pickle is now open…
I ordered the Brooklyn Pickle Special on dark rye with spiy deli mustard, lettuce, oregano, and sub oil. It was very good tasting and fresh.
D
Dimitrios D
1 contributions
3/15/25
• DoorDash order
My firt time getting food from Brooklyn Pickle
From 1-10 ratting definitely 10 in my book next time am going to visit the place
5 stars 7 days and two times on sunday
N
Nicole M
25 contributions
3/10/25
• DoorDash order
Homemade Chicken Noodle I'm mad I didn't order more than a cup. Definitely tastes homemade.
Hot Daily Chef's Special was the mac n cheese. If you aren't expecting all different types of cheese, it might be a shock. But very delicious.
J
Jeff D
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
2/6/25
• DoorDash order
The Brooklyn Pickle Special is always on fire. I also tried the Chicken Salad w mayo, American cheese and bacon... WOW!!! It was spectacular. You just cant go wrong at the BP!
L
LeighAnn C
9 contributions
3/26/25
• DoorDash order
I am pretty the people who left previous reviews were friends and family of this restaurant. The Brooklyn Pickle Special half of sandwich is nothing special the meat was deli sliced lunch meat like you would get from the deli counter at Harris Teeter, the swiss cheese was blah no real flavor, and there was so much house made Russian dressing that the pumpernickel bread was soggy. This was not a $9.75 sandwich.
