Best cookies in Gainesville. I always get the plain chocolate chip and chocolate chip with walnuts - I like the box of minis because the cookies are still pretty big. Plus the cookies always arrive warm and fresh!
J
James M
3 contributions
6/27/24
• DoorDash order
Always delicious and dependable. The Brown Butter cookies are to die for, as are the Oatmeal special with dried cranberry and white chocolate. I opted for the Rosemary Balsamic Fig, Chocolate/Walnut Chunk, Smores, and Pistacio for my 6. Cant recommend Brother Cookie enough and they arrived still warm and perfect texture.
C
Celeste K
2 contributions
2/17/24
• DoorDash order
I have ordered from Brother Cookie over the past 3 years, this place has the absolutely hands down BEST cookies you will ever have. Yes, even better than homemade. I've had all the flavors but I will say you are doing yourself a disservice if you don't try the browned butter cookie at least once. But any flavor is great I'd give them 6 stars if I could.
E
Ellie R
3 contributions
6/24/23
• DoorDash order
Wow... was debating whether to get Insomnia or what until found this place. Got 4 HUGE cookies for like $15 or so. The choc Chocolate Chip Cookie had a diameter of about 6 inches. Not a fan of the S'mores Cookie because it's cinnamon-y (just like a Graham cracker, tho). The Browned Butter Cookie was just perfect. The Double Chocolate Cookie was like a straight brownie. Will be ordering from here again 100%
A
Aurii H
1 contributions
10/25/23
• DoorDash order
I ordered 2 Brown Buttered Cookies, 2 Monster Cookies, Chocalate Chunk Walnut Cookie, and a Carrot Cake Cookie. They were all very moist and soft and delicious
