Celestino's Pizza opened for Business on April Fool's Day, April 1, 1997. They had a simple plan: Offer Authentic New York thin-crust Pizza and they will come! The Downtown store is still owned and op…
Really good pizza, pasta, and more. I love the ranch as well. I wish they sold the squeeze bottles of ranch on DoorDash like East ave location does in the shop. I also recommend the meatball sub and calzones (both are huge, but calzone is mostly filled with ricotta). The white sauce is fire on pizza!
N
Nocturne K
2 contributions
7/16/25
• DoorDash order
This place used to be way tastier. I spent $10 on the Fried Mozzarella Sticks because they looked like fried bricks of cheese in the photo but when they arrived, they were like jimmy Dean sausages (only 6 for $10 btw) with too much breading that had been reheated. Definitely not worth the $$. The cannoli was good. I wish the food tasted better. Not sure what happened
A
Amanda H
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
3/14/24
• DoorDash order
Love the slice combo, always hits the spot. Add a soda and you're over the $12 min for $0 delivery fee. The pizza is always hot and crisp and salad is fresh with the best ranch in town.
R
RebaAnn G
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
9/2/22
• DoorDash order
Minimum 3 meals out of this order and everything is perfect. Highly recommend the Caesar. Not quite as good as Broadway Heights, but at half the price it's a decent second for sure. Everything came packaged well with the extra sauces and everything! Zero complaints, happy customer.
K
Krystal G
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
7/30/24
• DoorDash order
Love the flavor of these Garlic Knots. if you're having a hard time deciding between just cheese and pesto ranch, totally go for the pesto ranch. Super 🔥. The Cannoli is always a great after meal snack or before meal snack. Perfect blend of sweet and creamy. And last but definitely not least, the Chicken Club 14". Made to order, and the classic Celestinos taste. One of my all time faves! Always worth the price. $$
$= 30$, $$= 60$, $$$=$90+
