Cookie Society was born from the shared passion of Marissa and Jeff Allen, a husband-and-wife team. Marissa, a lifelong baking enthusiast, was inspired by a famous NYC bakery known for its incredible …
I love, love, love the salted caramel Six Big Cookies
K
Kayla S
1 contributions
1/18/25
• DoorDash order
SO GOOD !!! Frosted sugar cookie is my fav
N
Nikki R
4 contributions
1/16/25
• DoorDash order
The cookies are hard and not very tasteful. The banana pudding doesn't taste like that at all let alone no banana taste.
J
Janet H
Local Expert • 88 contributions
12/29/24
• DoorDash order
SERIOUSLY AMAZING!! From care of packaging, presentation and pure deliciousness, Cookie So iety exceeded all expectation. The Oatmeal Cream Pie is now my all-time favorite cookie. It looked fantastic and tasted even better. The Brownie came cradled in a wrapper like that of a cupcake. It was moist, chocolatey and the perfect proportion. You can bet I will be ordering more of these decadent treats in the near future.
2+
S
Sheena S
5 contributions
11/13/24
• DoorDash review
Omg! I was not ready!!! Soooo good 10/10 best oatmeal cream pie I've ever had in my life!