I absolutely recommend the loaded crust. Tastes so cheesy and delicous. expected it to taste like that loaded crust pizza in high school that was absolutely disgusting and was pleasantly surprised by how amazing it is. I also reccomend the halal pepperoni instead of traditional... it's so savory and tangy. They also have a great deal on cheese pizza for those who don't like pepperoni (buy one get one free). East of Chicago pizza nails it every single time. Definitely my #1 go to pizza place!!!
K
Kevin Y
1 contributions
9/24/24
• DoorDash order
Both the 14" Build Your Own Pizza and the wings were tasty.
If you're thinking 14 in is small for being their largest size, it is.
The wings were little tiny things, I don't mind paying a reduced price for very small wings. but these were not cheap.
A
Anthony R
7 contributions
3/15/25
• DoorDash order
Honestly disappointed, ordered well done 10 Piece Boneless Wings got soggy wings, ordered 14" Buffalo Chicken Pizza as in the photo it was made with chicken tenders however the one I received had grilled chicken on it..ordered the Double Chocolate Brownie Pizza Cookie received a chocolate chip cookie. Ordered Breadsticks (6) with cheese got a cluster of bread sticks with a sprinkle of cheese. They are usually good here but the last couple times have been a disappointment. And for $80 definitely not happy.
H
Harpreet H
1 contributions
4/23/24
• DoorDash order
If you're in Rochester and craving some seriously good pizza, East of Chicago Pizza is the spot. I had their classic pepperoni pizza, and it was amazing. The crust was crispy yet soft, the sauce was tangy and just sweet enough, and the cheese was perfectly melted. They didn't skimp on the toppings either—lots of crispy pepperoni. The place has a friendly vibe, the service is quick, and the prices are fair. If you want the best pizza in Rochester, give East of Chicago a try. You won't be disappointed!
J
John C
Emerging Expert • 19 contributions
7/10/24
• DoorDash order
Chicken was good and they didn't count exactly 20 so the amount/size was great as well and came with 2 good sized cups of sauce as i ordered sauce on the side. The happy hour deal was great. I'll try something else from here using the offer again as this was a great meal.
