Fat Sully's is our new favorite pizza place! Our order arrived so quick! It was still hot and fresh! They are very generous with their toppings and the pizza is huge. The garlic knots are delicious but they're almost more like a fried donut consistency. We will order from them again and again.
R
Rona M
18 contributions
9/21/23
• DoorDash review
As a NY native I will say this is a pretty damn good pie!!!! Only downfall is as it cools the crust is very tough! Garlic knots are spot on. I just wish there was an option for garlic butter vs .red sauce. most UPSTATE NY folk like garlic butter, not red sauce. Also dry wings need to be advertised as served dry, sauce comes in little cups for you to toss yourself! Colorado is BIG for serving stuff dry. NY people want the stuff smothered in sauce and ready to go! All and all it was the best advertised NY meal we have had in Colorado!
A
Ashley K
5 contributions
6/27/23
• DoorDash order
This was seriously the best pizza I have had in a VERY long time. I loved everything about the pizza. The crust, soft and delicious, the sauce, flavor without the heartburn!, the toppings - FRESH cheese, FRESH toppings. Absolutely a must try. I even called to check on something and the staff (female) that answered was so friendly and so helpful. 10/10!!! Thank you so much for a wonderful experience and very happy and full bellies!!
M
MaryEllen G
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
7/21/24
• DoorDash order
Outstanding!! Boys devoured it before we could photo. The red sauce had the perfect acidity and savory. The crispy pepperoni. White sauce was brilliant!! Onions candian bacon and garlic!! Yummy!! Dough was perfect.
J
Jessica D
3 contributions
11/4/23
• DoorDash order
Where to start... I ordered a Caesar Salad, and according to the photo should be normal leaves of Romain; however, the salad I received was shredded Romain lettuce. I do not care for shredded lettuce in any kind of salad.
Second, the Perfectly Plain Garlic Knots were only fine. As they are fried, they are very chewy. Difficult to eat more than 1. The sauce was just ok.
Third, the pizza itself had a taste I could only guess was overtly oniony. It was a very different flavor than I've ever had in a pizza - and this comes from even making my own.
Since the only option was the 20", I now have 7 out of 8 large slices left that I am going to throw away because I had to choke down the one slice.
