Ordered a large (they don't have medium, just small, large, and extra large) and it was huge. Two pieces and I was stuffed! The value is incredible, $19 for a 1-topping large and had more of a mom-n-pop traditional taste than any chain pizza place I've had before. The only issue I had was that I ordered extra sauce but I think I got extra cheese instead (if you love a lot of cheese, you'll like how much they add plus there was no upcharge for extra sauce or cheese). I'll order from them again! (Put penny in photo to show how large this pizza was)
P
Pamela A
2 contributions
5/3/24
• DoorDash order
Always a excellent choice for a family of 5 or more the pizza is huge alone and the taste is the same as a New York style pizza
P
Patrice K
17 contributions
12/17/23
• DoorDash order
I'm very disappointed! Thin crust veggie pizza. The crust should be crispy. What little crust there was was soggy. When picking up the slice, it flopped straight down, depositing the topping on the plate. The slice had to be folded like a sandwich and supported with both hands to eat it. Way to many black olives and very little of anything else on it.
P
Peggy H
6 contributions
7/4/24
• DoorDash review
Our favorite pizza. Always fresh and hot!!!! Salad is good and fresh. Always our go to store for pizza and salad.
L
Lisa K
9 contributions
12/14/24
• DoorDash order
This was my first time ordering 5 Star, for the competition, they are AWESOME! Love their pizza, New York Style would def order again.
