Gib's Bagels has been offering original, tasty New York style bagels in northern Colorado for over 20 years. According to Mike Howland, proprietor of Gib's Bagels in Fort Collins, Colorado, the key to…
The best bagels I've eaten in Fort Collins. The variety of sandwiches and toppings is great. My favorite is the NYC with extra lox. Friendly staff and nice store vibe.
C
Catherine S
3 contributions
5/14/25
• DoorDash review
Sadly This place has gone way down hill...we had frozen stale bagels delivered this morning...obviously they are not baking them fresh in the morning any longer! and they were like a Bagel Jerky.
The one star is for the cream cheese as it was decently good.
Sad to say this once wonderful place was so great only to become such a disappointment.
J
J M
21 contributions
6/9/24
• DoorDash order
The British Islander and S'mores iced coffee were incredible (got extra shots so it wouldn't be too sweet and it was just right for our preferences) and the Breakfast Sandwich was yummy but the Reuben could have been better..it needed more meat and the corned beef didn't taste fresh. Being an authentic NY Bagel place from what I could tell, I had higher hopes for the Reuben, especially with the price.
C
Crysta S
2 contributions
3/21/25
• DoorDash order
Not only is the Breakfast Sandwich always a 10/10, the signature lattes are great too. My fav quick/easy (and fast!) breakfast for a Fri morning.
F
Felicia G
1 contributions
2/20/25
• DoorDash order
I always get this sandwich and have never had issues with it. I asked for lightly toasted, my bagel was hard, almost too hard to bite even, and tasted stale. :/ kinda sad about it. I just ate the middle
