Grumpy's Pizza Co. is not your traditional pizza spot! Chef Cello and his wife Nicolle opened the doors in January of 2022 in Saddle Brook, NJ. They bring big portions and even bigger flavors to every…
$30 for a pizza and I feel like im underpaying. It's that good.
B
Barrett W
4 contributions
5/13/25
• DoorDash order
This place is normally a 5/5 but the 16" Mushroom Truffle Pizza had no truffle that I could taste. For a $30+ pizza id hav expected that truffle heavier.
J
Jack R
Local Expert • 24 contributions
3/27/25
• DoorDash order
First time ordering and it was incredible. Be sure to get the dressing on the side for the Half Caesar Salad, because you'll have some left for tomorrow! They have a pie with double the pepperoni as the 10" Pepperoni Pizza, but I can't imagine where it could fit -- there was so much! Fantastic experience, and this place was immediately added to my favorites.
J
Jennifer C
2 contributions
2/21/25
• DoorDash order
I never heard of pizza crust being made from sourdough but holy canoli it is really amazing. the pesto sauce, the pizza sauce the fresh mozz all comes together yum. I got the everything season crust bc I read it was good on someone's review but it's so freaking good either way
J
Jennifer C
2 contributions
2/20/25
• DoorDash order
my latest obsession. the sourdough bread makes all the difference. the ratio of ingredients is spot on. I can't wait to try the pizza next
