Dear Pizza Lover, Gus’s New York Pizza in Tempe is the ORIGINAL Gus’s. Unlike the other guys, who may have frozen vegetables, we use only the freshest produce. Our dough and sauce are made from scra…
Very very tasty. 32" Pizza was well baked and wonderful crust, not soggy, plenty of toppings. fed five people easily with leftovers, for an amazing price!Garlic Knots were flavorful and also not soggy! 10/10 would order again
B
Brandi P
Emerging Expert • 8 contributions
4/23/25
• DoorDash order
Fries are like the kind you get from a frozen bag at the grocery store with a bunch of salt thrown on top, same with the mozzarella sticks with cold sauce that seems like it's from the dollar store and then the Tiramisu is about 4 bites of a smashed corner of cake. Not impressed.
J
Jessica G
2 contributions
12/31/24
• DoorDash order
I work night shift as a nurse & when I got home this morning I was craving pizza so bad! I had no idea this place was 24 hours but I will be telling all my fellow night shifters about them. We ordered the 14" Pizza with pepperoni and it did not disappoint, it was also HUGE. If you are a ranch dipper, theirs is SO GOOD (some places give you hidden valley in a cup and this is not one of them.. literally so good). We also got the Garlic Cheesy Bread and it wasn't stated on Door Dash but it does come with 2 marinara cups and 1 garlic butter cup (we ordered extra marinara because we didn't know but the serving size of the cheesy bread is so generous that we used it anyways)!
C
Chris D
2 contributions
6/26/23
• DoorDash order
After a twenty-plus year hiatus, my spouse and I moved back to Tempe and we soon ordered a pizza from Gus's. It was as good as we remembered. The crust was thin and light. The toppings married together well (mushrooms, red onion, and mozzarella). it was absolutely delightful!
R
Racheal G
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
10/26/24
• DoorDash order
The Tiramisu from Gus's is incredible, I'm obsessed. Generous portion for the $4.99 price.
Sometimes I order just to get the tiramisu :)
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Toasted Subs
Our toasted subs are baked and served on white or wheat bread with your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion, green pepper, oil & vinegar, mayonnaise, mustard, Italian & ranch dressing.
