Gyro Jimmy takes pride in serving real Greek gyros created from scratch. Gyro Jimmy's delivers an authentic Greek experience in the heart of Carle Place, using only the finest ingredients. You may eat…
Hands down the BEST greek takeout. Their pita bread is chewy and delicious. Tzatziki and hummus is thick and creamy. Pita chips are addictive. The chicken soulvlaki meat is always juicy and well seasoned and they load their gyros and salads with meat. The Lunch #1 special is a good sized salad with a lot of meat, pita, dressing and tzatziki for like $12.50. I dont like normally like Grape Leaves, but something about theirs is addictive. They come slighlty warm and they're tangy and tender. The Lentil Soup broth has so much flavor. I order from here at least once a week. One of my fav places.
E
Emely Q
13 contributions
8/25/22
• DoorDash order
The chicken sandwich is so goood! As well as the Traditional sandwich 👌 Worth your money and big quantity sandwich👍👍 Five stars worth! The taziki sauce is not too sour and just right. The meat has a stronger flavor than the chicken if you're interested. The chicken is soft and easy to eat. Love it! This is my first time and not my last😁
J
John Adriel A
1 contributions
5/21/25
• DoorDash order
This is probably the closest thing to the original gyro in Greece in terms of taste, atleast here in nassau county. I'd give this a 3star because they're stingy with the fries and it's $14 Pork Gyro - Sandwich , but like I said just because it tastes like the ones that I had in Athens I'll give this a 4star. Defo this can be 5star if they're not stingy
Y
Yamile P
2 contributions
3/12/24
• DoorDash order
I got the Chicken Souvlaki - Sandwich and was very disappointed. It was mainly lettuce stuffed pita bread, three pieces of chicken and three French fries inside the sandwich. The sauce was thick and not flavorful. Skip it.
I
India Q
11 contributions
3/19/24
• DoorDash order
I really was under with this place. The food just didnt have any flavor. I also didnt love how they packed the food. The Chicken Gyro - Plate was all packed together. The chicken was bland. I had a cucumber and tomato salad, and fries. All were packed together in a circular to go container. Dressing was on the salad which got on the fries and made them soggy. It also got on some of the chicken gyro meat which actually helped that small portion. The salad should have been packed separately. The lamb gyro meat was very overcooked and also bland. Overall very disappointing!
