Honestly the best ice cream I've ever eaten. I've tried several. The banana cream pie has chunks of graham crackers and marshmallow cream swirled in it. It tastes just like the pie! Coffee chocolate chip is another favorite. You won't be disappointed.
G
Gabriel R
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
11/11/24
• DoorDash order
I was really excited to try this community staple, the flavors I picked spoketi me in different ways and I was looking forward to seeing their take on it. The delivery was fine, but from the pictures I anticipated beautiful and appropriate packaging for ice cream, instead what i received was a cheap plastic container (like the ones the come with deli sandwich at the gas station) with four scoops of ice cream (barely) inside. I forgave the creamy mess in the bag and chalked it up to local quirkiness, the taste was reallyall that mattered...and it did!
Of my four hand-picked flavors, one was incorrect, insteadof the very exciting strawberry oreo i received regular oreo which tasted delicious, but was not what ihad psyched myself for. The Graham Cracker flavor tasted just right and was a joy to have, except for thw bits in the ice cream that make it a biycrunchy but also a bit chewy, perhaps a little less of that? As a standard measure of success i also ordered simple chocolate ice cream, in my opinion, if you can ace that flavor, then you're on track to success. Unfortunately it was not the case here, it ddnt taste right and it wasnti creamy and voluptuous or sweet enough. To close i had another classic: birthday cake. This last one deserves special mention because its appearance was so deformed and... blue, that it looked more like someone had killed the Cookie Monster and hid the body in my vanilla ice cream. The taste was a little fragrant, too far probably because of all that unnecessary blue dye. I will try anything twice, as they say, so hopefully by the next time i order, they'll have been able to figure out some of the stuff they have only been open since 1945...!
K
Kyle G
3 contributions
10/14/22
• DoorDash order
#1 is the chocolate peanut butter brownie ice cream. It's like crack with the thick chunks of PB and brownie.
#2 is the chocolate dipped mint ice cream stick.
U
Ureesha Q
Local Expert • 133 contributions
8/26/23
• DoorDash order
The best ice cream! Good price on the Waffle Cones!
J
Jessica D
7 contributions
8/16/22
• DoorDash order
They used to have the best pistachio but they went cheap and took the nuts out of the ice cream. I kept giving chances for it go back to how it used to be but 3 times my entire quart of ice cream had two nuts in it. Sucks. They got popular and like everything else cut corners to be cheap.
