Hot Cookie has been a Castro institution since 1997, with a vast assortment of freshly baked, chewy cookies, the infamous Penis and Vagina Cookies, and a wall of hot customers posing in our unique Hot…
these cookies are so soft & decadent. the Mini Saint Ginger Snap Cookie should've been 2 for 1.50 but that aside they were SO GOOD! perfectly chewy. Peanut Butter Cookie is soft & rich. Cookie of the Month (chocolate & mint) doesn't taste like mint at all in my opinion, just a nice chocolate cookie with some type of frosting and sprinkles. if you're someone who just wants a chocolate cookie & hates mint, you'll be able to enjoy it
J
Jehmima C
Emerging Expert • 9 contributions
6/19/25
• DoorDash order
I love Hot Cookie! I always order the Hunky Monkey Cookie because it is gluten free (and delicious) but just discovered they have a new gluten free cookie as well, the Monster Cookie! The bakery replaced the Hunky Monkey with a Monster Cookie because they could not fulfill the whole order of Hunky Monkeys, and I am happy to report that the Monster Cookie is a great cookie as well! Glad to now have two gluten free options!
S
Shelly A
Local Expert • 61 contributions
2/1/25
• DoorDash order
Hugh Toffee Milk Chocolate Cookie . soft centers with crispy edges.. Oatmeal Raisin Cookie and Peanut Butter Cookie well worth the cost
J
Jon L
2 contributions
6/25/23
• DoorDash order
For a $5.50 cookie, I had higher expectations. I got two Toffee Milk Chocolate Cookie. There were different sizes, thicknesses, and doneness. If this is their star product, I question their adherence to standards and procedures, and their quality control.
T
Tyler K
3 contributions
3/23/24
• DoorDash review
In all my years on this earth this is the best cookie I've ever had. Perfect for satisfying a late night cookie craving. Im partial to the snickerdood and classic chocolate chip. Best enjoyed with a glass of milk.
