Hot Cookie has been a Castro institution since 1997, with a vast assortment of freshly baked, chewy cookies, the infamous Penis and Vagina Cookies, and a wall of hot customers posing in our unique Hot…
these cookies are so soft & decadent. the Mini Saint Ginger Snap Cookie should've been 2 for 1.50 but that aside they were SO GOOD! perfectly chewy. Peanut Butter Cookie is soft & rich. Cookie of the Month (chocolate & mint) doesn't taste like mint at all in my opinion, just a nice chocolate cookie with some type of frosting and sprinkles. if you're someone who just wants a chocolate cookie & hates mint, you'll be able to enjoy it
M
Mitchell C
5 contributions
2/25/25
• DoorDash order
May be the best cookies ive ever had
J
Jennifer B
3 contributions
2/6/25
• DoorDash review
Love these big scrumptious cookies, a favorite if you appreciate a little decadence!
S
Shelly A
Emerging Expert • 56 contributions
2/1/25
• DoorDash order
Hugh Toffee Milk Chocolate Cookie . soft centers with crispy edges.. Oatmeal Raisin Cookie and Peanut Butter Cookie well worth the cost
V
Vanessa R
5 contributions
3/13/23
• DoorDash order
Omg. Absolutely delish Oatmeal White Chocolate Chip Cranberry Cookie is to die for!! Satiates all of my cookie desires:) the Toffee Milk Chocolate Cookie is also a heavy hitter! They arrived as scheduled soft and *almost warm;)
