Since 1983, when Phil Wenger opened up the first Isaac’s, we have been known throughout South Central Pennsylvania for our uniquely grilled sandwiches named after birds (and flowers for our vegetarian…
I love the southwest salad, my sister in law gets the Gooney Bird and says its the best. I love that I can get amazing food and throw in a side of dino nuggets for my son. The Sea Salt & Brown Butter Marshmallow is to die for. im not even a big rice krispie person and i have to get it every time we order. Highly recommend!
A
Angela K
Local Expert • 56 contributions
7/9/25
• DoorDash order
the Mallard sandwich was excellent!! the sauce had just enough horse radish. there was enough bacon,but it would have been better if the bacon was crispy.
<<taggedItemId=11814941927>>Salted Caramel Crunch
I<</taggedItemId>> had this in the store. I thought the slice could have been bigger. It seemed like a piece was missing. This cake was awesome. I loved the Caramel in the cake.
X-Large Iced Tea. The tea was very good.
S
Shakeena C
1 contributions
5/19/25
• DoorDash order
The bread on the sandwich was burnt and special instructions were not followed. The Chicken Tenders & Fries were nowhere near what was pictured nor were they extra crispy. Very disappointing for the price.
J
Jeff M
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
4/27/25
• DoorDash order
The Hawaiian Phoenix was excellent but the side of potato salad was really poor and flavorless. My Small Daily Soup (crab/broccoli) looked like dog food and really didn't taste all that good. There were no lumps of crab meat and it really didn't taste like crab either. For the price ($20 for the sandwich, $9 for the soup) I felt like I got ripped off.
S
Sharon M
6 contributions
8/26/23
• DoorDash order
I was shocked when I received my order of Honey-Dijon Chicken Salad from Issac's. The entire contents of the salad was just dumped into this cardboard box. There was too much as I had to try & find a bowl of some kind to put it into. It tasted ok but it just wasn't the same. I have never received a salad dumped into a cardboard box, which looked as though it was about to fall apart.
With the high prices I would think they could at least have put it in something else.
