The food was excellent. I ordered two large trays, and I must say, the reviewers seem to have missed the mark. The pizzas are generously sized and satisfying. The ingredients are well-layered and evenly distributed. The ricotta had a delightful lemon-infused flavor, which is quite unique for a pizza. I absolutely loved it. My only suggestion would be to substitute ham with anchovies on the pineapple pizza. You can thank me later. For a party of two, I highly recommend two large trays. They’re thick, perfect for sharing, and you’ll still be pleased the next day.
T
Tyler M
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
7/20/25
• DoorDash order
I now believe in Detroit-style pizza because of Johnny Pomodoro. It has all the appeal of South Shore bar pizza but like it was prepared by your Italian Noni. A bite of their Crispy Pepperoni Cup begins like a spinning axe kick to the face followed by the warmest hug that made every all better.
T
Tyler M
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
2 days ago
• DoorDash order
I grew up on South Shore Bar Pizza, and this is my first Detroit-style Pizza (at least that's what I think it is? pardon my ignorance if so.
NO MATTER! lol the Crispy Pepperoni Cup is just straight up baller: if you have cravings for the bar/pan/sheet pizza browned in a well-seasoned & blackened pan kind of vibes, Johnny Pomodoro slaps so hard. The cheese is phenomenal, everything is fresh, delivers really well, and they don't put "pomodoro" in their name for nothing: it's topped with a bright tomato sauce that balances all the flavors. Pepperonis? Fuhgedaboutit. It's got the smallest sweet flavors of tomato fruit & a kiss of honey. No complaints ever, multiple orders. I'll never be a skinny boy.
M
M L
3 contributions
2/21/23
• DoorDash order
The pizza was decent but was undercooked. Cheese was was barely melted.
The Garlic Knots were soggy and chewy in the worst way, and Mozzarella Sticks were cold and soggy, and came with a weird lettuce & scallion salad on top that made the entire thing taste like lettuce. Both are *grossly* overpriced.
Not worth a try, stick with your usual pizza spot.
M
Maria M
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
9/3/24
• DoorDash order
The Mozzarella Sticks were good. The Crispy Pepperoni Cup pizza was extremely disappointing. The whole crust just tasted like sugar, which is clearly how they get it to look crispy and caramelized... but it is super off-putting and tasted like a weird dessert. Maybe I got a bad batch, but I definitely won't be trying it again. Really not good.
