Johns of Arthur Avenue Pizzeria
4.6(500+ ratings)•
DashPass•
Sicilian•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(500+ ratings)•
•Sicilian
Welcome to John's of Arthur Ave Restaurant in Middletown, NY, where you may have a wonderful pizza! We're a neighborhood pizza with fresh cuisine, pleasant service, and delighted customers. With that …
All Day
10:00 am - 9:45 pmMost Liked Items From The Menu
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Courier tracking may be different for this store
This store decides if its courier or a Dasher delivers your order. The store and its courier may receive your name, address, delivery instructions, and phone number to help deliver to you. Learn More
Most Liked Items From The Menu
Reviews500+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.6
of 5 stars
B
Brittany B
4 contributions2/22/25
• DoorDash orderjohns has the best pizza in Middletown hands down. their salads are amazing and their wings are very good.
L
Lisa J
7 contributions11/2/24
• DoorDash orderJohns of Arthur Avenue is consistently excellent on every order that I have gotten... the meatballs here are also the absolute best!!!
P
Pamela G
1 contributions1/21/22
• DoorDash orderThe food was nice and hot. delivered way before the expected arrival time which is awesome.
B
Brittany B
4 contributions2/1/25
• DoorDash orderbest pizza spot hands down
T
Taneesha M
13 contributions1/26/25
• DoorDash orderAlways great food and service
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Appetizers
Antipasto.
Salads
Little Italy Entrées
Individual dinners come with bread. Add soup or salad for an extra charge.
Little Italy Entrées à La Carte
Arthur Ave. Pasta Shop
Individual dinners come with bread. Add soup or salad for an extra charge.
Arthur Ave. Pasta Shop à La Carte
Arthur Ave. Style Pizza
Thin and crispy crust, zesty sauce, and aged grande Mozzarella. Our Mozzarella is made fresh daily.
Sicilian Pizza (Square)
Calzones
Served with tomato sauce.
Hero Sandwiches
Featuring our own homemade Mozzarella and Italian sourdough bread. The recipe made especially for us by Defilippis.
Wraps
Served with French fries or side salad.